978-1-6654-3760-8/22/$31.00 ©2022 IEEE
Quantification Method for Assessment of Asteroid
Resource Accessibility
Kevin I. Alvarado
Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering
Clarkson University,
8 Clarkson Ave., Potsdam, NY 13699
alvarakl@clarkson.edu
Michael C.F. Bazzocchi
Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering
Clarkson University,
8 Clarkson Ave., Potsdam, NY 13699
mbazzocc@clarkson.edu
Abstract—Asteroid mining and retrieval have been explored as
viable alternatives to supplying resources from Earth for space
missions. Various methods for determining the accessibility of
near-Earth asteroids have been presented; however, this
method focuses on the quantity and types of resources that are
available within a certain energy constraint given a redirection
time frame. Lambert’s problem is solved to determine the
optimal transfer orbit between the Earth and asteroid for
rendezvous. A genetic algorithm is used to determine the
minimum energy for transfer with varying flight durations and
launch dates. The physical properties and spectral
classifications of known asteroids are used to estimate the
quantity and chemical composition of accessible resources. This
method is applied to asteroids that have assigned taxonomic
classifications. An overall distribution of asteroid types and
energy requirements is presented for Earth and investigated for
a sample asteroid scenario.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................... 1
2. BACKGROUND......................................................... 1
3. PROBLEM FORMULATION ...................................... 3
4. TECHNICAL APPROACH ......................................... 3
5. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION..................................... 5
6. CONCLUSION........................................................... 9
REFERENCES............................................................... 9
BIOGRAPHY .............................................................. 10
1. INTRODUCTION
As space exploration continues to increase, more resources
will be utilized for space missions. Rocket launches for
resupplying missions are expensive overall as a tremendous
amount of energy is required to overcome the atmosphere and
gravity of the Earth. Rather than using the Earth itself for
resources, it has been explored as a possibility that other
celestial bodies could be used for mining. The nearest
celestial body to Earth that can be mined for resources is the
Moon. Some have studied and reviewed the potential for
lunar mining, but it remains unclear as to the quantity and
accessibility of desired resources [1, 2]. Resource utilization
analyses have been performed for near-Earth asteroids
(NEAs) [1-10]; however, the rapid increase in NEA
discovery and characterization requires the development of a
general method that can be readily applied to a large dataset
in order to understand the resource accessibility of the NEA
population. A general method can further be applied to
estimate asteroid materials accessible to other planets,
particularly in cases where few alternatives exist for in situ
resource utilization.
There are several beneficial resources that can be obtained
from asteroids within the solar system. These resources
include metals, silicates, water, and other volatiles for
extraction and use in situ. Asteroid compositions and
specifications are often difficult to determine, but through
spectral and meteoritic analyses, general trends can be
estimated. Different types of impulsive and low-thrust
maneuvers for asteroid redirection to an orbit around the
Earth have been proposed [3-6, 8]. Further research is
required on the formulation of a general method for asteroid
redirection to an arbitrary target body while assessing the
type and quantity of resources available.
The goal of this research is to develop a general method for
determining the quantity and type of resources available to a
target body. The method is validated through analysis of the
accessibility of resources to the Earth from near-Earth
asteroids. The proposed method requires solving Lambert’s
problem and implementing a stochastic optimization scheme
for obtaining the minimum energy transfer for rendezvous
within a given time frame. The asteroids are further evaluated
based on their spectral classification and mass properties to
estimate the quantity and type of resources available. The
accessibility of known asteroids further allows for estimation
of general trends when asteroid information is uncertain or
unknown.
2. BACKGROUND
Development of new technologies in the aerospace industry
have made spaceflight increasingly accessible to the public.
However, the cost to place resources in orbit still remains a
barrier for many space missions. For example, there is a
typical cost of about $10,000 per pound to send materials to
low-Earth orbit [11]. Although there have been some recent
reductions in costs due to the use of reusable rockets, launch
costs remain a persistent challenge. Furthermore, rocket
launches from Earth are very inefficient due to the propulsive
losses required to overcome the atmosphere and gravity. To
support missions beyond low-Earth orbit requires a