Journal of critical reviews 2139
Journal of Critical Reviews
ISSN- 2394-5125 Vol 7, Issue 14, 2020
ATTITUDE TOWARDS ROMANTIC RELATIONSHIPS: A CROSS-CULTURAL STUDY
AMONG INDIANS AND FILIPINOS
Remedios T. Navarro
1
, Ashim Abhilash Kumar Mohanty
2
, Edelyn A. Cadorna
3
, Sushama Pattnaik
4
1
University of Northern Philippines
2
University of Northern Philippines
3
University of Northern Philippines
4
Sambalpur University, Sambalpur, Odisha, India
Email:remediostnavarro@gmail.com
1
, mashimabhilash@gmail.com
2
, delwinkri@gmail.com
3
, sushamapattnaik27@gmail.com
4
Received:11.04.2020 Revised: 16.05.2020 Accepted: 10.06.2020
Abstract
This study examined the attitude towards romantic relationships and knowledge of HIV of 250 Filipino and 150 Indian students. It also
explored how the students’ profile and knowledge of HIV influenced their attitude towards romantic relationships. The comparative
research method determined the differences in the attitude towards romantic relationships and knowledge of HIV between the Indian
and Filipino students. The correlational method on the other hand, determined the influence of HIV knowledge and profile on their
attitude. The study utilized survey questionnaires to gather the needed data. Results show that there is a statistically significant
difference between the students of the two counties in their knowledge of HIV. Indian students are more knowledgeable about HIV than
the Filipino students. Both the Filipino and Indian students are undecided in their attitude towards romantic relationships. Number of
close friends and romantic relationships and knowledge of HIV significantly influence attitude towards romantic relationships of the
Filipino students. Personal factors and knowledge of HIV, taken singly and as a whole do not significantly influence attitude of the Indian
students towards romantic relationships.
Keywords: Romantic Relationships, HIV knowledge, cross-cultural study, Filipinos, Indians
© 2020 by Advance Scientific Research. This is an open-access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.31838/jcr.07.14.431
INTRODUCTION
Romantic relationships play a vital role in the lives of
adolescents. Sharma (n.d.) stated that the development and
negotiation of romantic relationships with the emergence and
integration of sexual behaviors into it as one matures are
considered important and normative developmental tasks.
Furman and Shaffer (2003) cited Sullivan who emphasized that
romantic relationships play a significant role in shaping the
adolescent’s general course of development. Romantic
relationships may impact key developmental tasks such as
identity formation, family relationship transformations, close
relationships with peers, sexuality, and career planning.
Blair and Madigan (2016) contended that the initiation and
maintenance of intimate, romantic relationships link with
improved physical and emotional well-being, stronger
perceptions of community attachment, and better developmental
outcomes.
Romantic relationships also have significant implications for
health and adjustment. They influence the emotional and social
development of adolescents, their future functioning and their
experiences and expectations of intimate relationships in
adulthood. Romantic relationships formed in adolescence may
affect adult relationships either by supporting/altering the way
individuals interact with potential partners or by giving concrete
outcomes like marriage, pregnancy, and STDs. Romantic
relationships and experiences – whether real, potential or
fantasized – account for many of the intense emotions both
positive (e.g., excitement, happiness), and negative (e.g. jealousy,
anger, distress) that adolescents undergo (Headspace,
2012)Adolescents engage in romantic relationships for varied
reasons: physical attraction, sense of intimacy and
belongingness, self-esteem and recognition. Conversely, they too
stay in a relationship for varied reasons.
Romantic relationships can occur in the context of one or
different cultures. Attitudes towards them and the way people
manifest them could vary from culture to culture. Karandashev
(2015) stated that culture has an impact on people’s conceptions
of love and the way they feel, think, and behave in romantic
relationships. As such, the success of romantic relationships
could be affected by cultural differences. Ecological perspectives
emphasize the social and cultural contexts that encourage or
constrain close relationships and give individuals meaning and
significance. Events that occur in other settings and relationships
inevitably affect adolescent romantic relationships and vice
versa. (Collins, Welsh, and Furman, 2009)The study of Prakas
(2016 ) on the attitude of Indians in New Zealand towards love,
marriage, and romantic relationships revealed a continued
endorsement of permanent and exclusive romantic relationships
though greater acceptance of premarital sex and cohabitation
was noted. The comparative study of young Indians and
Americans by Bejanyan, Marshall, Ferenczi (2014), on the other,
found that Indians reported greater collectivism and held
stronger romantic beliefs than Americans. Further, the Indians’
endorsement of more traditional gender roles partly
predicted their preferences for a marital partner possessing
traditional characteristics.
Sharma (n.d.) in her study concluded that the nature of sex and
romantic relations among the youth slum of Mumbai
Metropolitan seem to have changed. Casual sex seems to have
changed very fast their concept of true love. Their risky
behaviors also increased dangerously.
VOL 7, ISSUE 04, 2020
3929