Nuclear Inst. and Methods in Physics Research, A 977 (2020) 164306
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Nuclear Inst. and Methods in Physics Research, A
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/nima
Correlating the fissile mass of standard uranium samples with delayed
gamma rays from fission products
Fabiana Rossi
a,∗
, Tatjana Bogucarska
b
, Mitsuo Koizumi
a
, Hee-Jae Lee
a
, Bent Pedersen
b
,
Douglas Chase Rodriguez
a
, Tohn Takahashi
a
, Giovanni Varasano
b
a
Integrated Support Centre for Nuclear Nonproliferation and Nuclear Security, Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Tokai-mura, Naka-gun, Ibaraki-ken 319-1118, Japan
b
European Commission, Joint Research Center, Directorate for Nuclear Safety and Security, Nuclear Security Unit, Via Enrico Fermi 2749, 21027 Ispra (VA), Italy
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Delayed gamma-ray spectroscopy
Fissile mass
Non-destructive assay
Safeguards verification
ABSTRACT
The Japan Atomic Energy Agency and the European Commission Joint Research Centre are collaborating
to develop delayed gamma-ray spectroscopy (DGS) for nuclear materials for safeguards verification in
reprocessing plants. In this paper, we describe DGS interrogation using the Pulsed Neutron Interrogation Test
Assembly with standard samples of different
235
U enrichments. By analyzing gamma-ray spectra, we reveal a
linear correlation between the sample mass and both the total counts above 3.3 MeV and the peak counts
of specific high-energy gamma-ray. We were able to observe, qualify and quantify specific gamma rays peak
down to the depleted uranium (0.5 g
235
U) mass sample. Based on this, we demonstrate that our technique is
able to estimate the total fissile mass with a statistical uncertainty <2% when taking into account self-shielding
and gamma self-absorption corrections. Using integrated counts above 3.3 MeV we were able to reduce the
mass-dependent bias for the higher enrichments (∼3 to 4%) to <4%.
1. Introduction
The verification of nuclear materials is a key task in nuclear safe-
guards [1,2], particularly for reprocessing plants [3] where uranium
and plutonium can be found in multiple forms. Passive non-destructive
assay (NDA) techniques are currently used to verify low-radioactivity
nuclear material. However, these techniques are not applicable to high-
radioactivity nuclear material (HRNM) due to the intense neutron and
gamma-ray emissions that overwhelm the passive signature in the low
energy range [4,5]. For reprocessing plants, hybrid K-edge densitom-
etry (HKED) is applied to determine the U and Pu elemental masses.
The isotope dilution mass spectrometry (IDMS) DA method is used to
quantify the fissionable isotopic composition in the sample. However,
IDMS is time-consuming, produces waste, and requires the use of spikes
(certified tracers containing U and Pu) that have limited availability.
To avoid the drawbacks of DA, the Japan Atomic Energy Agency
(JAEA) is collaborating with the Joint Research Centre (JRC) of the Eu-
ropean Commission (EC) to develop a set of NDA techniques to quantify
nuclear material [6]. Of these, delayed gamma-ray spectroscopy (DGS)
is considered useful to quantify the ratio of fissile nuclides (e.g.
235
U,
239
Pu, and
241
Pu) in samples through analysis of high-energy gamma
rays from short-lived fission products [7].
DGS consists of an irradiation phase in which an external neutron
source is used to induce fission in a sample, followed by a measurement
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: rossi.fabiana@jaea.go.jp (F. Rossi).
phase in which the gamma rays are collected. This sequence is repeated
for several cycles to achieve statistical significance [8,9]. Due to the
presence of long-lived fission products emitting strong gamma rays in
the low energy range (e.g.
137
Cs at 662 keV), which mask the gamma-
ray signatures of short-lived fission products below ∼2 MeV, we here
focused DGS on a high energy range (≥3 MeV).
However, the total fissile mass in the sample is needed for verifi-
cation purposes [1,2]. Similar to passive techniques, the total fissile
mass can be assessed with differential die-away analysis (DDA) that
evaluates the fission neutrons over an extended time [10]. As presented
in previous studies [7,11–13], the detection of delayed gamma rays
with energies above 3 MeV after the induction of fission in nuclear
material is possible, even for small quantities of the material. In these
studies a hint of correlation between the sample mass and the gamma-
ray counts were observed, therefore we tried here to improve upon
these results. Thus, the challenge was to use high-energy gamma rays
for the fissile mass evaluation. This will open the possibility to integrate
and combine DGS and DDA for the fissile mass evaluation in safeguard
verifications, implementing a double double-check measurement using
different signature and reducing results uncertainty. Moreover, combin-
ing these with HKED for the total elemental mass it will be possible to
verify the
235
U enrichment.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2020.164306
Received 18 February 2020; Received in revised form 10 June 2020; Accepted 25 June 2020
Available online 27 June 2020
0168-9002/© 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.