Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum, May 2022, 8(2):139-146
DOI 10.22146/jcef.3797
Available Online at https://jurnal.ugm.ac.id/jcef/issue/archive
Development of a Density Gauge for Measuring Water and Mud Density
based on a Radioactive Technique
Aloysius Bagyo Widagdo
*
National Research and Innovation Agency, INDONESIA
*Corresponding author: aloy001@brin.go.id
SUBMITTED 11 October 2021 REVISED 2 December 2021 ACCEPTED 7 January 2022
ABSTRACT The density or concentration of mud is one of the key variables in studying cohesive sediments, due to being accumulated
through settlement and consolidation, as well as resuspended through erosion. This indicates that the proper measurement of sediment
density is important. Therefore, this study aims to evaluate the accuracy of density measurement by using the gamma-ray attenuatioan
method as a non-intrusive technique. For Compton Scattering, gamma-ray attenuation was effectively independent of mineralogy,
subsequently depending on only the electron density of material, which is directly related to the bulk density of the mixture. Based on
the results, the advantages of utilizing the nucleonic density gauge indicated that the technique was non-intrusive and very flexible for
many experimental arrangements, as well as the high accuracy of measurements with errors less than 1%.
KEYWORDS Density; Cohesive sediment; Nucleonic gauge; Non-intrusive; High accuracy
© The Author(s) 2022. This article is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International license.
1 INTRODUCTION
The experimental methods for determining the
density of sediments are generally categorized as
(i) sampling, and (ii) in situ direct measurements.
This sampling method involves weighing an accu-
rately known volume of samples obtained through
a siphon, pipette or other devices. Meanwhile,
the in-situ direct technique involves optical or
acoustic instruments, which are non-intrusive al-
though requires calibration to produce absolute
sediment concentrations. These methods have
presently been applied in studying suspended lay-
ers with materials coarser than mud (i.e., silt and
sand). In several previous decades, the initiation
of applying the principle of gamma-ray attenua-
tion was conducted in measuring the bulk den-
sity of cores and sediment samples. This method
was used for the in-situ measurement of bulk sea
bottom sediment density (Preiss, 1968a,b; Rose
and Ronsy, 1971; Krishnamurthy et al., 1973; Ger-
land and Villinger, 1995; Blum, 1997), where ver-
tical distribution was determined at distances be-
tween 2-5 cm, with the accuracy of +1%. It was
also applied for measuring the spatial variability
of soil bulk density (Pires et al., 2009). Further-
more, the gamma-ray attenuation method was
used as a proof-of-concept for non-intrusive and
undisturbed measurement of sediment infltration
masses. This led to a good accuracy with a devia-
tion of less than 5% (Mayar et al., 2020).
Based on this present study, the development
and evaluation of a nucleonic density gauge are
required, as a non-intrusive method for the ac-
curate concentration measurements of mud pro-
fles. This density gauge is a device for measur-
ing the attenuation of a collimated gamma-ray
beam after passing through a test material, e.g.,
the sediment-water mixture. The gauge utilized
in this application uses a 111 MBq source, which
emits a narrow collimated beam of gamma-rays at
662 keV. At this energy level, attenuation is found
to occur by the Compton scattering of the inci-
dent gamma-rays from the collimated beam. This
method is non-intrusive and has the additional
important advantage that the calibration factor
(i.e., the ratio between the measured gamma-ray
attenuation and the calculations from the pub-
lished coeffcients of the kaolin and water com-
139