The Role of Physical Health Functioning, Mental Health, and
Sociodemographic Factors in Determining the Intensity of
Mental Health Care Use Among Primary Care Medical Patients
Brenda M. Lindsay Nour
The University of South Dakota
Jon D. Elhai
University of Toledo
Julian D. Ford
University of Connecticut Health Center
B. Christopher Frueh
Baylor College of Medicine
The present study examined sociodemographic and attitudinal predisposing factors (gender,
age, marital status, health insurance, household income, attitudes about mental health care),
and need/illness variables (depression severity, physical and mental health functional status)
as predictors of past-year mental health care use intensity (i.e., visit counts) and use/nonuse.
The sample included 283 adult primary care patients from the Midwestern United States in
a cross-sectional study. Nonlinear regression models demonstrated that past-year treatment
use intensity was significantly associated with both married status and poorer physical
health functioning, while the use (vs. nonuse) of treatment was associated with depression
severity. A sociodemographic and attitudinal multivariate predictor model only explained
5% of the variance in treatment use intensity, but a need/illness model significantly
contributed an additional 23% variance. Poorer physical health functioning was significant
in predicting treatment use intensity, while depression severity was significant in predicting
the use (vs. nonuse) of treatment. Results demonstrate the particular importance of physical
health problems in determining the intensity of mental health care use, and depression
severity in determining the use/nonuse of treatment, notwithstanding the restricted socio-
demographic contour of the sample.
Keywords: primary care, health disparities, mental health service use, functional impairment,
behavioral model of health care use
A significant disparity continues to exist be-
tween the need for and actual use of mental
health services nationally. For instance, studies
of the general population indicate that between
only one fifth to one third of individuals with a
mental disorder recently sought mental health
care (Kessler, Demler et al., 2005). Among the
minority of those in need of treatment who do
seek mental health care, a significant proportion
appear to prefer discussing their mental health
problems with their primary care physicians,
thus bypassing the mental health specialty ser-
vice sector (Del Piccolo, Saltini, & Zimmer-
man, 1998; Wang et al., 2006). However, rela-
tively little research has sufficiently explored
factors that predict primary care patients’ use of
mental health care.
The Behavioral Model of Health
Service Use
One important and widely used theoretical
framework for understanding individual determi-
nants of health care use is Andersen’s behavioral
model of health care use (Andersen & Newman,
Brenda M. Lindsay Nour, Department of Psychology,
The University of South Dakota; Jon D. Elhai, Department
of Psychology, University of Toledo; Julian D. Ford, De-
partment of Psychiatry, University of Connecticut Health
Center, Farmington, CT; and B. Christopher Frueh, Men-
ninger Clinic and Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral
Sciences, Baylor College of Medicine.
This paper is based on Brenda M. Lindsay Nour’s doc-
toral dissertation; she is now affiliated with the Avera Be-
havioral Health Center, Sioux Falls, SD. Dr. Frueh is now
with the Department of Psychology, University of Hawaii at
Hilo.
Declaration of Interest: No competing or financial inter-
ests are reported for the authors regarding this paper.
Correspondence concerning this article should be ad-
dressed to Jon D. Elhai, Department of Psychology, Uni-
versity of Toledo, Mail Stop #948, 2801 W. Bancroft St.,
Toledo, OH 43606-3390. E-mail: jonelhai@gmail.com
Psychological Services © 2009 American Psychological Association
2009, Vol. 6, No. 4, 243–252 1541-1559/09/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0017375
243
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.