Int J Colorectal Dis (2002) 17:402–411
DOI 10.1007/s00384-001-0389-9
Accepted: 21 December 2001
Published online: 7 March 2002
© Springer-Verlag 2002
Abstract Background and aims: To
assess the effect on irritable bowel
syndrome (IBS) of treating ano-rec-
tal problems by applying multiple
Barron’s bands to prolapsing mucosa
and excising haemorrhoids, with or
without a low lateral sphincterotomy.
Patients and methods: 144 patients
with IBS whose ano-rectal abnor-
malities were treated by a single
consultant surgeon. A prospective
‘within person’ study of consecutive
patients referred with ano-rectal
problems who also had IBS symp-
toms according to the Rome criteria.
All patients completed structured
questionnaires about anal and IBS
symptoms before operation and
6–60 months later. The findings
were compared with those from pa-
tients who had no abdominal pains.
Results: The principal IBS symp-
toms of abdominal pain, abdominal
distension, and altered bowel habit
all improved significantly after oper-
ation. Those with persistent anal
problems had more problems with
persistent IBS symptoms, but when
the anal problems were corrected,
the IBS tended to settle. Posterior
anal tenderness is present in 80% of
IBS patients and is a useful diagnos-
tic sign. Conclusions: This work
suggests that in many patients with
IBS there is a physical ano-rectal
disorder amenable to physical treat-
ment. Patients with IBS should all be
proctoscoped carefully, with and
without the patient straining, looking
for abnormalities. Correcting muco-
sal prolapse and other anal problems
produced an improvement in IBS
symptoms in 86% of patients. This
suggests that ano-enteric reflexes are
a significant factor in irritable bowel
syndrome, if not the major cause.
Keywords Haemorrhoids · Fissures ·
Surgery · Irritable bowel syndrome
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Bernard V. Palmer
W. John Lockley
Robert B. Palmer
Elena Kulinskaya
Improvement in irritable bowel syndrome
following ano-rectal surgery
Introduction
It is a medical truism that where there are many differ-
ent treatments, the disease is not understood properly.
Nowhere is this more the case than for irritable bowel
syndrome (IBS). It has been estimated that 10–25% of
otherwise healthy persons in Western countries suffer
from IBS [1,2]. The major symptom of lower abdomi-
nal pain is probably due to colonic spasm as screening
of barium enemas has demonstrated a correspondence
between peristaltic contraction in the colon and the
usual pain [3]. It has also been suggested that bowel
atony is largely caused by increased sympathetic activ-
ity [4].
What could initiate these reflex spasms or atony?
Stress is well known to alter intestinal function in normal
persons [5], and this can be exacerbated in patients with
IBS [6]. Many studies have shown that mood and per-
sonality disturbances are all more common in IBS pa-
tients [7]. However, persons with IBS who do not con-
sult their physician appear to have psychological profiles
that are similar to those without symptoms [8], and
therefore it has been suggested that the psychoneurosis is
in part secondary to the bowel symptoms [9].
B.V. Palmer (
✉
)
39 Pasture Road, Letchworth,
SG6 3LR, UK
e-mail: bernardpalmer@ntlworld.com
Tel.: +44-1462-683064
Fax: +44-1462-643872
B.V. Palmer
Lister Hospital, Corey’s Mill Lane,
Stevenage, SG1 4AB, UK
W.J. Lockley
Health Centre, Oliver Street,
Ampthill, MK45 2SB, UK
R.B. Palmer
36 Sunlight Square, Birkbeck Street,
London E2 6LD, UK
E. Kulinskaya
H.R.D.S.U., University of Hertfordshire,
College Lane, Hatfield, AL10 9AB, UK