Vol.:(0123456789) 1 3
CEAS Aeronautical Journal
https://doi.org/10.1007/s13272-018-0344-x
ORIGINAL PAPER
Potential of integrated fight scheduling and rotation planning
considering aerodynamic-, engine- and mass-related aircraft
deterioration
M. Lindner
1
· J. Rosenow
1
· S. Förster
1
· H. Fricke
1
Received: 1 March 2017 / Revised: 14 September 2018 / Accepted: 14 November 2018
© Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt e.V. 2018
Abstract
Aircraft are subject to steady deterioration efects in fight operations resulting in increased fuel consumption due to decreased
engine efciency, increased airframe surface roughness and increased operating empty mass. These efects are taken into
account in operational fight planning (e.g. fuel calculations) but long-term efciency loss is rarely respected in fight and
rotation scheduling. In most cases, each aircraft type per feet series is treated homogeneously and scheduled considering
maintenance events, equipment and other restrictions. This work investigates fuel saving potentials by additionally consider-
ing the aircraft tail sign-specifc efciency during aircraft to fight assignment. For this purpose, we calculate additional fuel
consumption caused by deterioration efects, expressed as performance factor and mass deviation. By using an integrated
fight scheduling and aircraft rotation model, aircraft will be reassigned to fights from given fight schedules by minimiz-
ing operating costs or fuel consumption. Our research yields in a saving of 22,400 kg fuel for 15 long-haul aircraft (150 kg
per reassigned fight on average) based on a fight schedule for a typical week of an air cargo operator. The saving potential
depends on the number of fight legs, their distance and the number of available aircraft, their performance variation and
loading factor. Although relative savings are of theoretical nature and marginal to total fuel burn (0.2%), we propose an
inexpensive approach to decrease total fuel consumption. Furthermore, we show that the usual approach of assigning less
efcient aircraft to short fight legs is applicable but does not always provide in the cost minimum solution because low
cruising altitudes of short-haul fights adversely afect fuel consumption.
Keywords Flight schedule optimization · Aircraft rotation assignment · Aircraft deterioration · Performance deviation
factors
1 Introduction
1.1 Motivation
Although airlines’ proftability has increased in recent years,
an efcient operational planning and scheduling is essential
due to a highly competitive market. Especially the assign-
ment process of aircraft to fight-legs signifcantly infuences
airline’s direct operating costs (DOC), because the DOC not
only depend on feet type, but also on each individual aircraft
[1]. It is well known that ageing processes of engine and
airframe as well as increased aircraft operating mass empty
(OME) impact aircraft’s fuel burn up to 6% [2–4]. Most
airlines, as well as aircraft’s fight management systems
(FMS) consider those efects already in order to improve
fuel calculation, using a specifc performance factor. This
imposes an interesting research question, which is addressed
in this paper: do diferences in aircraft performance (due to
deterioration of aerodynamics, engine, and mass) and the
resulting diferences in fuel consumption reveal a cost sav-
ing potential in the tail assignment process? The authors’
experience is that a small number of airlines claim they use
deterioration in the aircraft assignment, whereas others do
not consider such an assignment criterion. If they do, a linear
fuel consumption factor is printed as a decision support list
for manual planning of long-haul feets. In this way, the ben-
eft is unclear to the planner, which reduces the motivation
* M. Lindner
Martin_Lindner@tu-dresden.de
1
Institute of Logistics and Aviation Chair of Air Transport
Technology and Logistics, TU Dresden, 01069 Dresden,
Germany