Wetting of New SnAg Surface Finish
Alena Pietrikova
1)
, Daniel Dzivý
1)
, Olga Vrublenskaya
2)
, and Marina A. Shikun
3)
1)
Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Informatics Technical University of Kosice, Kosice, Slovakia
2)
Research Institute for Physical Chemical Problems of the Belarusian State University, Minsk, Belarus
3)
Belarusian State University, Minsk, Belarus
alena.pietrikova@tuke.sk
Abstract: This paper shows how a surface finish does affect wettability. Four standard lead-free alloys
selected for surface finishes on PCB (LF HASL, ImSn, ENIG, and Cu) with a newly developed surface
finish based on SnAg7 alloy were compared. Wetting characteristics of surface finishes were analysed
using the spreading rate method and a method based on wetting reflow pattern, both in laboratory
condition. Experiments were supplemented by analysis of the effect of plasma on the flux activity, and
eventually on wettability. A self-developed equipment was applied to evaluate the spreading rate. The
spreading rate method allows for real-time measurement of contact angle of liquid SAC 305 solder balls
on various PCB surface finishes. The method based on wetting reflow pattern by SAC 305 solder paste
applied on various PCB surfaces confirms these wetting characteristics. The wettability of the new and
relatively cheap SnAg7 surface finish is almost comparable with surface finish based on ENIG. This new
surface finish is a prospective material that offers interesting properties for application in electronics.
1. INTRODUCTION
The wettability of a surface by a liquid depends
primarily on the contact angle between the surface and
molten solder ball in a liquid state. The contact
(wetting) angle as well as the spreading rate of molten
solder are important parameters in determining the
wettability of the molten solder on a solid substrate.
Motivation for the study how does surface finish affect
wettability are various industry aspects. However, in
the case of soldering in electronics it is necessary to
take into account that it is a reactive wetting, in which
a reaction takes place between the spreading solder and
the solid substrate. Wettability is influenced by surface
energy and this is related to the option of PCB surface
finish [1, 2, 8, 9]. The production price, reliability and
variability of application of other technological
processes are also important. This paper focuses on the
wettability characteristics of a new surface finish and
our first analyses point to promising results of the use
of this SnAg based finish [3].
In addition to temperature, wetting also depends on
the type of surface treatment and the overall state of the
surface energy. ENIG (electroless nickel/ immersion
gold) based PCB finish began to be used in electronics
as an alternative at the end of the last century, at a time
when electronics was looking for a substitute for lead,
which was part of the Hot-Air Solder Leveling-based
(HASL) coating [4]. This surface treatment is charac-
terized by long-term reliability while maintaining a
well-wettable surface, so manufacturers have started to
use it more and more. However, the problem is the high
price and also the corrosion of nickel, which is
associated with black pads. From the point of view of
reliability, the organic solderability preservative
(OSP), Immersion tin (ImSn), immersion Ag and also
lead-free HASL (LF HASL) are also used as an
alternative to lead. Each of these surface finishes has its
advantages and disadvantages.
In our article, we present a new type of surface
finish based on SnAg. This type of PCB surface finish
has not yet been applied in the field of SMD
technology.
The wettability of various PCB surface finishes was
evaluated by a self-developed method that allows for
the real-time measurement of the contact angle under
laboratory conditions. The wettability of standard
surface finishes was compared with the newly-
developed surface finish based on SnAg. Within this
experiments we investigated an effect of combination
flux - plasma on wettability as well.
978-1-6654-6589-2/22/$31.00 ©2022 IEEE 1 45th Int. Spring Seminar on Electronics Technology (ISSE)
2022 45th International Spring Seminar on Electronics Technology (ISSE) | 978-1-6654-6589-2/22/$31.00 ©2022 IEEE | DOI: 10.1109/ISSE54558.2022.9812833
Authorized licensed use limited to: Technical University Kosice. Downloaded on November 28,2022 at 11:58:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.