IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON APPLIED SUPERCONDUCTIVITY, VOL. 27, NO. 6, SEPTEMBER 2017 5900809
Influence of the Striation Process and the Thickness
of the Cu-Stabilization on the AC Magnetization
Loss of Striated REBCO Tape
Aur´ elien Godfrin, Anna Kario, Roland Gyur´ aki, Eduard Demenˇ c´ ık, Rainer Nast, Juliane Scheiter,
Alexey Mankevich, Alexander Molodyk, Wilfried Goldacker, and Francesco Grilli
Abstract—Rare earth-based coated conductors have large ac
magnetization losses, which hinder their use in a variety of ap-
plications. A common way to reduce these losses is by striating the
superconductor into narrow filaments by means of laser ablation.
Practical superconductors also need a sufficiently thick copper sta-
bilization. The best way of creating copper-stabilized filamentized
coated conductors is still to be found. In this paper, the ac magneti-
zation losses of differently prepared 12 mm wide coated conductors
manufactured by SuperOx were measured. The samples differ in
terms of thicknesses of copper stabilization (5 and 10 μm), num-
ber of filaments (from 10 to 60), and order for copper deposition
(filaments produced before or after electroplating the tape). The ac
loss measurements were performed at 77 K in a wide range of fre-
quencies of the external magnetic field, which allows determining
the onset of coupling currents and the importance of the coupling
losses. Complementary dc measurements of the transverse resistiv-
ity between filaments help to understand the path of the coupling
currents. Thanks to the variety of tested samples and operating
conditions, this paper provides a direct comparison of the two
striation processes in commercially available high-temperature su-
perconductor coated conductors.
Index Terms—AC loss measurement, ac magnetization losses,
high-temperature superconductors, multifilamentary supercon-
ductors, transverse resistivity.
I. INTRODUCTION
R
ARE earth-based coated conductors (CCs) are currently
regarded as the most promising high-temperature super-
conductor tapes because of their high current carrying capability
and good in-field behavior. For applications such as transform-
ers and electrical machines, however, the dissipation caused
by perpendicular ac magnetic fields is too large, and repre-
sents a serious refrigeration burden. For example, the ac loss
requirements for an all-superconducting generator operating at
500 Hz are discussed in [1].
Manuscript received November 4, 2016; revised March 9, 2017; accepted
April 27, 2017. Date of publication June 26, 2017; date of current version
July 21, 2017. This paper was recommended by Editor-in-Chief B. Plourde.
(Corresponding author: Aur´ elien Godfrin.)
A. Godfrin, A. Kario, R. Gyur´ aki, E. Demenˇ c´ ık, R. Nast, W. Goldacker,
and F. Grilli are with the Institute for Technical Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of
Technology, Karlsruhe 76344, Germany (e-mail: aurelien.godfrin@kit.edu).
J. Scheiter is with the Department of Superconducting Materials, Leibniz
Institute for Solid State and Materials Research, Dresden 01171, Germany.
A. Mankevich and A. Molodyk are with SuperOx, Moscow 117246, Russia.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TASC.2017.2716820
A common approach to reduce the ac magnetization losses
is by striating the tape into narrow filaments. The idea was
originally proposed by Carr and Oberly in 1999 [2]. The results
of the intense and widespread research carried on filamentization
and reduction of the ac losses that followed have been recently
summarized in a review article [3].
The most common process to realize the filamentized struc-
ture is laser ablation. Its successful application to tapes with
thick copper stabilization is, however, not straightforward [4]
due to the difficulty of controlling the quality of the grooves and
avoiding filament coupling [5].
In this contribution, we study the applicability of the laser
ablation technique for producing copper-stabilized filamentized
tape. In our previous work [6], significant ac magnetization
losses reduction was observed for tapes with 5 μm thick copper
stabilization. Here, we investigate the reduction of ac magneti-
zation losses in CCs where the filaments are produced before
or after the deposition of the copper layer (5 and 10 μm thick).
Transverse resistance measurements and scanning electron mi-
croscopy (SEM) photographs are used to interpret and support
the results of ac loss measurements.
II. SAMPLE PREPARATION
All the tapes used in this work are 12 mm wide and were
manufactured by SuperOx [7]. The filaments were created by
means of a TRUMPF TruMicro 5025 laser. This laser has an
infrared wavelength of 1030 nm, a pulse frequency of 400 kHz
with pulse duration less than 10 ps, and a maximum power
of 25 W with maximum pulse energy of 125 μJ. The typical
width of the groove is 20 μm. More details about this striation
technique can be found in [8].
The striations were produced at Karlsruhe Institute of Tech-
nology (KIT) either before or after deposition of the copper
layer. Throughout this paper, the two types of samples are iden-
tified as striated before electroplating (SBE) and striated after
electroplating (SAE), respectively. Samples with different thick-
nesses of copper for the stabilization (5 and 10 μm) and different
numbers of filaments (10, 20, 40, and 60) were produced. As it
will be shown later, the actual thicknesses of the copper stabiliza-
tion are different from the expected values due to the technical
difficulties related to the electroplating technique. Nevertheless,
for sake of clarity, throughout the manuscript we keep the the-
oretical values of 5 and 10 μm for labeling the samples.
1051-8223 © 2017 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.