RESEARCH ARTICLE
A bi‐level stochastic framework for VPP decision making in
a joint market considering a novel demand response scheme
Ehsan Ghorbankhani | Ali Badri
Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Shahid
Rajaee Teacher Training University,
Tehran, Iran
Correspondence
Ali Badri, Faculty of Electrical
Engineering, Shahid Rajaee Teacher
Training University, Lavizan, Tehran,
Iran.
Email: ali.badri@srttu.edu
Summary
This paper presents a stochastic decision‐making framework for an optimal bid-
ding strategy of a virtual power plant (VPP) in a joint day‐ahead and regulation
(balancing) market. The VPP seeks to maximize its expected profit in day‐ahead
market and compensates its deviation in balancing market. Due to the inherent
uncertainties of renewable energy resources and also other market participant
strategies, a stochastic programming is used for underlying optimization prob-
lem. In this regard, a 2‐stage bi‐level problem is presented in which upper level
represents VPP profit maximization and lower level deals with market clearing
problem in which power transfer distribution factors are used to incorporate
transmission constraints. Uncertainties related to stochastic generation and
market participant offer/bid curves are modeled via scenarios. A mathematical
programming with equilibrium constraints is obtained by reformulating the
lower‐level problem using Karush‐Kuhn‐Tucker optimality conditions. The
resulting mathematical programming with equilibrium constraints is converted
into a tractable mixed‐integer linear programming problem with strong duality
theorem. The considered VPP is assumed to be commercial and consists of sto-
chastic generation units (wind and solar), conventional power plant, energy
system storage, and adjustable internal loads. A novel demand response scheme
is introduced into the VPP portfolio in which VPP is penalized through shifting
load amount and operating time interval as well. Finally, a trade‐off between
profit and risks associated with uncertainties is explicitly taken into account
using the conditional value at risk. To assess the validity and the effectiveness
of the proposed model, a 6‐bus test system is chosen to apply the model.
1 | INTRODUCTION
The mounting concerns of energy crisis by running out fossil fuels in the near future have attracted worldwide attention
to substitute these sources of energy by an alternative energy sources. All these sources have the common and outstand-
ing features of very low operation costs, sustainability, and being well replenished. Among them, wind and solar by the
high production capacities are of great importance. The most critical drawback of these sources is their unpredictability,
which poses a great challenge to the system operator. So the approach towards them is fundamentally different, and the
way they are dispatched should be distinct from conventional generation sources.
Generally, electricity markets consist of 2 main sections which the vast majority of transactions take place there: the
day‐ahead market and the regulation market. In day‐ahead market, the market operator clears the market via market
Received: 28 April 2017 Revised: 25 July 2017 Accepted: 17 September 2017
DOI: 10.1002/etep.2473
Int Trans Electr Energ Syst. 2017;e2473.
https://doi.org/10.1002/etep.2473
Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/etep 1 of 18