Matrix Vol. 911989, pp. 486-488
Stress in Collagen Fibrils of Articular Cartilage
Calculated from Their Measured Orientations
R. M. ASPDEN
1
and D. W. L. HUKINS
2
1 Department of Medical and Physiological Chemistry, University of Lund, P. O. Box 94, S-221 00 Lund,
Sweden and
2 Department of Medical Biophysics, University of Manchester, Stopford Building, Oxford Road, Manches-
ter M13 9PT, England.
Abstract
Articular cartilage may be considered as a form of pressure vessel in which the internal swelling
pressure is balanced by tensile stress in the collagen fibrils. This stress is calculated by analysing
the tissue as a series of microscopically small pressure vessels. The previously measured orienta-
tions of the collagen fibrils describe the structure necessary for this calculation. The stresses and
strains developed in the fibrils are shown to be well within physiological limits.
Key words: articular cartilage, cartilage mechanics, collagen organisation.
Introduction
Articular cartilage is comprised of collagen fibrils, which
are strong in tension, surrounded by a highly hydrated gel
of proteoglycans. Unloaded cartilage has an internal swel-
ling pressure of about 0.3 MPa (Maroudas, 1976) and this
swelling pressure is resisted by the collagen fibrils which are
thereby put into tension. The orientation of the collagen
fibrils are therefore important if they are to be able to
reinforce the gel. The organisation of collagen fibrils has
been measured using x-ray diffraction and polarised light
microscopy in patella, femoral head and tibial plateau
articular cartilage (Asp den and Hukins, 1981a, b; Yarker
et aI., 1983; 1984). These measurements show that the
organisation of the collagen fibrils may be described in
three distinct zones that merge smoothly into each other on
passing from the articular surface to the bone. There is no
neccessity for an individual fibril to be continuous from one
zone to the next, they will effectively reinforce the ground
substance providing their length is greater than a critical
length (Hukins et aI., 1984; Hukins and Aspden, 1985).
Collagen fibrils at the articular surface are oriented pre-
dominantly in the plane of the surface. Fibrils reorient
through a transition zone, in which the preferred orienta-
tion is either bimodal or random, until in the deep zone,
© 1990 by Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart
adjacent to the bone, the preferred orientation of the fibrils
is approximately perpendicular to the articular surface.
This structure is very similar to that described by Benning-
hoff (1925) in which the arcades he used to illustrate the
fibril directions are the locus of the fibrils.
This structure lead to the proposal that articular cartilage
functions in a similar way to a pressure vessel in which the
internal pressure is resisted by tension in the walls of the
vessel (Hukins et aI., 1984). The collagen fibrils in the
surface zone are appropriately oriented to provide a tension
resisting structure to such a vessel. Calculations made using
this model suggested that the stress in the collagen fibrils at
the articular surface was of the order of 10 MPa and that,
given the degree of orientation and the volume fraction of
collagen, the surface zone was strong enough to support
this stress.
Analysis
The calculations were originally performed using pig
femoral head as an example, as it has an approximately
spherical surface, and the equation used was that for a
spherical pressure vessel for which
0= rP/2t (1)