Metastable Phase Evolution in TiO
2
-YO
3/2
-ZrO
2
Tobias Schaedler
1
, Solome Girma
2,3
, Ashutosh S. Gandhi
1
, Sanjay Sampath
2
, Carlos G. Levi
1
1
Materials Department, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA, USA
2
Center for Thermal Spray Research, State University of New York, Stony Brook, NY, USA
3
RISE intern, Materials Department, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA, USA
ABSTRACT
The metastable-to-equilibrium phase evolution over a wide range of compositions in the TiO
2
-
YO
3/2
-ZrO
2
system was investigated. The competing phases are all derivatives of the fluorite
structure and compositions within the fluorite and pyrochlore fields exhibit technologically inter-
esting ionic and mixed ionic-electronic conductivity. Powders of various compositions were
synthesized by precursor routes, pyrolyzed and subsequently heat-treated in a stepwise manner at
progressively higher temperatures to explore the sequence of phase evolution. Extended solid
solutions with amorphous, fluorite and ordered pyrochlore structures were produced over signifi-
cant composition ranges within the ternary. The study also sheds new light on the correct form
of the phase equilibria at 1300°C.
INTRODUCTION
Solution synthesis routes for multicomponent ceramic oxides enable molecular-scale mixing of
precursors that, upon subsequent pyrolysis, often yield amorphous phases with novel composi-
tions. Upon additional heat treatment at temperatures wherein long-range diffusion is kinetically
constrained the amorphous oxide may evolve through a series of metastable states before reach-
ing the equilibrium configuration [1]. Systems where metastable states are kinetically stable
over significant periods of time offer the opportunity to investigate the relationship between al-
ternate structures of a fixed composition and its properties.
The ternary TiO
2
-YO
3/2
-ZrO
2
(Fig. 1) [2] is ideally suited for fundamental studies of metastable
phase selection because of the structural relationship between the competing phases. Notably,
pyrochlore ( Fd 3 m ) and bixbyite ( I a 3 ) are ordered superstructures of fluorite ( Fm 3m ) [3, 4]
while tetragonal (P4
2
/nmc) and monoclinic (P2
1
/c) ZrO
2
, ZrTiO
4
(Pcnb) and even rutile
(P4
2
/mnm) may be envisaged as distorted forms of fluorite [5]. Moreover, the fluorite and pyro-
chlore structures in this system exhibit technologically relevant ionic and mixed ionic-electronic
conductivity [6]. The present paper is part of a broader effort aimed at understanding the ther-
modynamics and kinetics governing phase selection in this system in the context of conventional
precursor routes and precursor-based thermal spray processes. It is also intended to clarify some
inconsistencies in the current description of the phase equilibria. Specifically, Fig. 1 proposes a
two-phase field between fluorite and rutile whereas other works suggest equilibrium between
pyrochlore and ZrTiO
4
, [7, 8], which would negate the existence of the former at the same tem-
perature. The longer-term goal is to synthesize metastable structures with sufficient stability to
enable the study of the effects of crystallization, ordering and phase separation on ionic/mixed
conductivity.
K3.11.1 Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. Vol. 835 © 2005 Materials Research Society