Fluid Phase Equilibria 240 (2006) 161–166
Excess properties of aqueous mixtures of methanol:
Simulation versus experiment
Diego Gonz´ alez-Salgado
a, 1
, Ivo Nezbeda
a,b, ∗
a
E. H ´ ala Laboratory of Thermodynamics, ICPF, Academy of Sciences, 165 02 Prague 6, Suchdol, Czech Republic
b
Department of Chemistry, J.E. Purkinje University, 400 96
´
Ust´ ı n. Lab., Czech Republic
Received 9 October 2005; received in revised form 6 December 2005; accepted 6 December 2005
Abstract
We report molecular simulation results for both the excess mixing and partial molar properties of water–methanol mixtures over the entire
concentration range with the particular emphasis on the low concentration ends. It is shown that the mixing properties are very sensitive to potential
models and that the used realistic potentials (TIP4P for water and OPLS for methanol) give a reasonably good agreement with experiment only
for volumetric properties although the qualitative trend of the partial molar volume at low concentrations is not reproduced. As regards excess
enthalpy, the results are rather bad and only its sign is predicted correctly.
© 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Aqueous mixtures; Water–methanol mixtures; Solutions of alcohol; Excess mixing properties; Partial molar properties
1. Introduction
Aqueous solutions of alcohols have attracted a good deal
of attention of both scientific and engineering community for
decades for a number of reasons. From the technological point
of view, such mixtures have served as useful industrial solvent
media for a variety of separation processes; moreover, recently
it has become popular to use them also in solar thermal systems
[1]. Physical chemists have been attracted by their eccentric,
unusual non-ideal behavior, especially in the low concentration
range [2]. Aqueous solutions of alcohols are also ones of the sim-
plest aqueous solutions with the solute having both a hydrophilic
head and hydrophobic tail. They therefore attract nowadays also
attention of biochemists because it is believed that the full under-
standing of their behavior may provide insight into the behavior
of certain biological systems and may thus serve as a spring-
board for studying and modeling aqueous solutions of complex
amphiphiles that are difficult to simulate.
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +420 2 20390296; fax: +420 2 209 20661.
E-mail address: IvoNez@icpf.cas.cz (I. Nezbeda).
1
On leave of absence from: Department of Applied Physics,
Faculty of Science, University of Vigo, 32004 Ourense, Spain.
It is well known that the thermodynamic properties of water–
alcohol mixtures are significantly smaller than the values that
might be expected from an ideal mixture of the pure fluids.
Structural properties underlying this behavior were reviewed
by Frank and Ives in 1966 [3] and again in 1985 [4]. However,
the wide-spread and commonly accepted explanation of these
effects in terms of an enhanced structuring of water does not
seem to be supported by modern diffraction experiments [5,6].
Neutron scattering experiments supported by molecular simula-
tions based on an empirical potential obtained directly from the
diffraction data show highly heterogeneous mixing across the
entire concentration range despite apparent miscibility of both
components [6].
In the light of the yet unsettled controversy as for the origin of
the observed anomalies it is understandable that overwhelming
majority of molecular simulation studies have focussed on the
structure with very little attention paid to the thermodynamic
properties [7–11]. However, it has been well established that
not all interactions acting between the molecules contribute
equally to establishing the structure [12]. Thus, although the
observed macroscopic properties are superimposed on the
underlying structure, they may result from a more complex
interplay between various intermolecular interactions. Detailed
simulation studies of the thermodynamic behavior revealing
such relations seem therefore equally important.
0378-3812/$ – see front matter © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.fluid.2005.12.007