Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Energy Storage
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/est
Numerical simulation and validation of commercial hot water tanks
integrated with phase change material-based storage units
Manfredi Neri
a
, Eliodoro Chiavazzo
a
, Luigi Mongibello
⁎
,b
a
Department of Energy DENERG, Polytechnic University of Turin, Italy
b
ENEA Research Center of Portici, Italy
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Thermal storage
PCM
Numerical models
Latent heat
Numerical simulation
Enthalpy porosity method
Experimental validation
ABSTRACT
Thermal energy storage (TES) allows to extensively exploit solar thermal technologies by efectively handling
the mismatch between energy production and demand thus possibly causing a downsizing of generation units.
Among thermal energy storage technologies, those based on phase change materials (PCM) are particularly
interesting because relatively large latent heat values may guarantee more compact systems (as compared to
sensible TES). In this work, we report a numerical and experimental investigation on a hybrid latent-sensible
heat storage characterized by a commercial hot water tank integrated with macro-encapsulated phase change
materials. Those hybrid systems are interesting as they can possibly increase the overall thermal capacity of a
sensible water tank. Despite all this, we demonstrate that increasing the efective storage capacity is a non trivial
task with standard conditions and materials. To this end, three diferent numerical models have been developed
and experimentally validated. The frst model is based on the enthalpy porosity method and simulates the charge
and discharge of a PCM storage unit in a climatic chamber. The second model is a one-dimensional description of
the water storage tank without PCM. Finally, the third model is obtained by coupling the previous two and
simulates the whole PCM-water thermal storage. This fnal model was validated through an experimental test,
which consisted in inserting 94 modules of PCM in the water tank and observing the resulting thermal behaviour
for three days, applying the load curve of a detached house of 200m
2
. The model proved to be very accurate,
with determination coefcients between 92.10% and 99.80% for the considered physical quantities (tempera-
tures and thermal powers). As a main contribution of this work, we proved that the hybrid thermal storage
system did not exploit the full latent heat potential of the PCM, since only 40% of it actually changes its phase,
due to is thermal transport properties that negatively afect heat transfer.
1. Introduction
The awareness on the importance of renewable energy sources to-
wards the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions today is gaining an
increasing popularity. However, especially solar and wind power are
highly variable and have an unpredictable behaviour. As a con-
sequence, they need to be coupled with storage technologies. In addi-
tion to more traditional uses, energy storage systems may be also
adopted for implementing smart energy management strategies. In fact,
relying on efective storage technologies, customers may decide to
purchase (at lower price) and store energy during of-peak periods for
later use, when the price would be higher [1]. Moreover, a properly
designed storage system may help in reducing the plant generation
power with a corresponding downsizing and installation cost reduction.
Among all types of energy storage technologies (electro-chemical,
mechanical, thermal, etc...), thermal energy storage (TES) is attracting
a large interest as it is a relatively mature and easily scalable tech-
nology. Sensible TES is very common in residential applications like
heating, cooling, air conditioning and domestic hot water. Large tanks
containing molten salts at high temperatures are often installed in
concentrated solar power plants, being one of the keys of the success of
this technology [2]. Direct thermal energy storage systems can be di-
vided into sensible heat thermal energy storage (SHTES) and latent heat
thermal energy storage (LHTES). In addition to direct TES, indirect TES
are manly based on reversible physi-chemical reactions, such as water
sorption in microporous sorbents [3–5]. Indirect TES are beyond the
scope of this work. Sensible heat storage is based on the variation of
energy due to a temperature diference in the storage material, which
usually is either liquid or solid. Packed beds of rocks are widely used for
sensible thermal storage in solar air heaters, due to their low-cost and
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.est.2020.101938
Received 6 July 2020; Received in revised form 14 September 2020; Accepted 25 September 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: luigi.mongibello@enea.it (L. Mongibello).
Journal of Energy Storage 32 (2020) 101938
2352-152X/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T