Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 68 (2022) 101458
Available online 22 September 2022
0278-4165/© 2022 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Multi-centric, Marsh-based Urbanism at the early Mesopotamian city of
Lagash (Tell al-Hiba, Iraq)
Emily Hammer
University of Pennsylvania, Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations Department & Price Lab for the Digital Humanities, Williams Hall, 255 S 36
th
Street, Philadelphia,
PA 19104, USA
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Mesopotamia
Ancient city plan
Early urbanism
Landscape archaeology
Remote sensing
Archaeological survey
ABSTRACT
Leveraging a suite of remote sensing technologies deployed over large areas, this paper presents results that
challenge long-held ideas about the origin and development of the world’s oldest urban centers, in southern Iraq.
The standard model of third millennium BCE Mesopotamian cities presents them as nuclear, compact settlements
set within an irrigated agricultural hinterland, expanding continuously from a monumental religious complex.
This reconstruction holds enormous infuence in the comparative global study of early urbanism. UAV photos
and magnetic gradiometry data captured at Lagash (Tell al-Hiba) show dense architecture and related paleo-
environmental features over c. 300 ha, revealing a city that does not conform to the standard model. Early
Dynastic Lagash (2900–2350 BCE) was composed of spatially discrete sectors bounded by multiple surrounding
walls and/or watercourses and separated by open spaces. The evidence is suggestive of a marshy or watery local
environment, and the city sectors may have originated as marsh islands. The discontinuous, walled nature of
inhabited areas would have had social and logistical ramifcations for city inhabitants. A number of contem-
porary sites are characterized by multiple archaeological mounds, suggesting that early southern Mesopotamian
cities may have frequently been spatially multi-centric.
1. Introduction
The world’s earliest cities developed in the fourth-third millennia
BCE between the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers in southern Iraq (Sumer,
southern Mesopotamia) (Algaze, 2008; Pollock, 1999; Van de Mieroop,
1997). Founded along river channels, already-large settlements grew in
the third millennium BCE Early Dynastic period (c. 2900–2350 BCE) to
cover dozens to hundreds of hectares and incorporated monumental
temples, residential areas, canals, and harbors. For decades scholars
have described southern Mesopotamian cities as nuclear, compact, hi-
erarchical settlements with a singular city wall (typically oval-shaped)
and set within an irrigated agricultural hinterland, expanding out-
wards in a continuous fashion from a central religious complex. The
identifcation of these characteristics as fundamental traits of early
Mesopotamian city form traces back to Childe’s (1936, 1942) defnition
of the “Urban Revolution”, and they have remained central to widely-
cited comparative discussions (e.g., Trigger, 2003: 120-131; Van de
Mieroop, 1997: 63-97).
Important aspects of this standard model of third millennium
southern Mesopotamian urban form have never been verifed, however.
Decades of confict have limited feldwork in southern Iraq and so
archaeological knowledge has remained largely constrained to data
collected by excavations in the early-to-mid-twentieth century. Many
southern Mesopotamian cities were continuously inhabited for thou-
sands of years, resulting in meters of accumulated cultural strata and
therefore excavators could only expose small windows relevant to the
period of initial urban growth. Further, excavations focused over-
whelmingly on temples and palaces, encouraging a biased, elite-
centered view of city life. The few studies of more extensive residen-
tial spaces concern neighborhoods of the second millennium BCE (Stone,
1987; Stone and Zimansky, 2004; Woolley and Mallowan, 1976), when
Mesopotamian communities had already been urban for more than a
millennium. With little empirical basis for a broader understanding of
early city form, synthetic discussions of Mesopotamian urbanism
amalgamate details from various periods, presenting an idealized pic-
ture of “the Mesopotamian city” that may not be accurate for any one
period, let alone the fourth-third millennia BCE period during which
cities were originally founded and greatly expanded.
A number of archaeologists have put forward alternative hypotheses
concerning early southern Mesopotamian cities’ origins, development,
and layout, but these models have remained fundamentally speculative
because spatially extensive and ground-truthed archaeological data do
E-mail address: ehammer@sas.upenn.edu.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Anthropological Archaeology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jaa
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaa.2022.101458
Received 12 April 2022; Received in revised form 14 July 2022;