1540 THE BONE & JOINT JOURNAL
ONCOLOGY
Radiofrequency ablation in the treatment of
cartilaginous lesions in the long bones
RESULTS OF A PILOT STUDY
E. F. Dierselhuis,
P. J. M. van den Eerden,
H. J. Hoekstra,
S. K. Bulstra,
A. J. H. Suurmeijer,
P. C. Jutte
From Department of
Orthopaedic Surgery,
University Medical
Center Groningen,
The Netherlands
E. F. Dierselhuis, MD,
Orthopaedic Resident
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery
P. J. M. van den Eerden, MD,
Radiologist
Department of Radiology
H. J. Hoekstra, MD, PhD,
Professor of Surgical Oncology
Department of Surgery
S. K. Bulstra, MD, PhD,
Professor of Orthopaedic
Surgery
A. J. H. Suurmeijer, MD, PhD,
Professor of Pathology,
Department of Pathology
P. C. Jutte, MD, PhD,
Orthopaedic Surgeon
Department of Orthopaedic
Surgery
University Medical Center
Groningen, Postbus 30.001,
9700 RB Groningen, The
Netherlands.
Correspondence should be sent
to P. C. Jutte; e-mail:
p.c.jutte@umcg.nl
©2014 The British Editorial
Society of Bone & Joint
Surgery
doi:10.1302/0301-620X.96B11.
33544 $2.00
Bone Joint J
2014;96-B:1540–5.
Received 4 December 2013;
Accepted after revision 17 July
2014
Atypical cartilaginous tumours are usually treated by curettage. The purpose of this study
was to show that radiofrequency ablation was an effective alternative treatment.
We enrolled 20 patients (two male, 18 female, mean age 56 years (36 to 72) in a proof-of-
principle study. After inclusion, biopsy and radiofrequency ablation were performed,
followed three months later by curettage and adjuvant phenolisation. The primary endpoint
was the proportional necrosis in the retrieved material. Secondary endpoints were
correlation with the findings on gadolinium enhanced MRI, functional outcome and
complications.
Our results show that 95% to 100% necrosis was obtained in 14 of the 20 patients. MRI
had a 91% sensitivity and 67% specificity for detecting residual tumour after curettage. The
mean functional outcome (MSTS) score six weeks after radiofrequency ablation was 27.1
(23 to 30) compared with 18.1 (12 to 25) after curettage (p < 0.001). No complications
occurred after ablation, while two patients developed a pathological fracture after
curettage.
We have shown that radiofrequency ablation is capable of completely eradicating
cartilaginous tumour cells in selective cases. MRI has a 91% sensitivity for detecting any
residual tumour. Radiofrequency ablation can be performed on an outpatient basis allowing
a rapid return to normal activities. If it can be made more effective, it has the potential to
provide better local control, while improving functional outcome.
Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2014;96-B:1540–5.
The mainstay of treatment for primary bone
tumours is surgery. Central atypical cartilagi-
nous tumours (ACT - formerly known as chon-
drosarcoma grade I) are generally treated by
curettage: previously, treatment consisted of
wide resection or amputation.
1
In general, the
treatment of chondroid tumours can be prob-
lematic, since they are relatively resistant to
irradiation and chemotherapy. It can also be
difficult to differentiate ACT from its benign
counterpart (enchondroma) and grade II
tumours.
2,3
In contrast to higher grade chon-
drosarcoma, ACTs grow slowly and do not
metastasise, unless upgrading or dedifferentia-
tion occurs.
4,5
Although curettage causes less
morbidity than more extensive surgery, it still
has a negative impact on functional outcome.
1
Local recurrence (LR) occurs in up to 7.7 %
of patients after curettage.
6
In the event of LR,
a repeat operation is often needed, exposing
the patient to the additional risks of common
peri-operative complications such as infection
or fracture. In addition, prophylactic hardware
is sometimes needed.
7
All these measures have
a negative effect on a patient’s quality of life.
Although the adage ‘life before limb’ remains
true for ACT, the relatively mild nature of
these tumours in the long bones might justify
less aggressive treatment.
Therefore, a new treatment strategy is needed
that improves local control and functional out-
come, while lowering the rate of complications.
Moreover, follow-up must be sufficient to eval-
uate the effect of such treatment. A minimally-
invasive approach using radiofrequency abla-
tion (RFA), monitored by gadolinium-enhanced
magnetic resonance imaging (G-MRI), might be
capable of meeting these requirements.
For nearly two decades, RFA has been used as
a minimally-invasive surgical technique in
orthopaedics. With RFA, a high-frequency
alternating current heats tissue to approxi-
mately 80°C, causing it to necrose.
8
Initially,
RFA was used to treat osteoid osteoma.
9,10
With
increasing clinical experience, bone metastases
and chondroblastomas have also been success-
fully treated.
11,12
Complications are rare,
although local adverse events such as cellulitis
or burns of the surrounding skin have been
reported.
9,10
When more challenging sites, such