1
PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT QUARTERLY
© 2020 International Society for Performance Improvement.
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI: 10.1002/piq.21350
Managerial Coaching
Competencies Used by Managers
for Performance Improvement
Karla D. Barry, PhD, Gene Gloeckner, PhD and Leann M.R. Kaiser, PhD
Introduction
I
n today’s organizations, managers are respon-
sible for employee learning and development
and improving employee performance (Ellinger
et al., 2003; Evered & Selman, 1989; Liu & Batt, 2010;
Segers & Inceoglu, 2012). With the role of perfor-
mance management shifting from human resource
development (HRD) to the manager, managers coach-
ing for performance improvement has become one of
the most popular tools and interventions to emerge in
HRD. According to Longenecker (2010), “For a man-
ager to produce sustainable long-term results, they
must demonstrate real skill at coaching the people who
report to them” (p. 32). As early as 1952, coaching was
identifed in the literature as a “worthy and acquirable
management skill” (Mace & Mahler, 1952, p. 99) and
a “management function” (Evered & Selman, 1989,
p. 32); however, a paucity of literature exists to support
that managerial coaching is occurring in organizations
today. Further review of the managerial coaching lit-
erature showed limited studies on the coaching com-
petencies used during coaching interactions. Coaching
competencies refers to the skills and behaviors used by
a coach in a coaching engagement. Only 18 studies/
dissertations discussed how managers viewed or used
the various competencies of managerial coaching. Terefore, our study
sought to explore the lived experiences of managers coaching their direct
reports with the coaching competencies espoused by the literature. Tis
study examined in detail which competencies (skills and behaviors) were
being used in coaching engagements with managers’ direct reports.
With our extensive backgrounds in HRD, learning and development,
and coaching, we often observed that HRD professionals and learning
This qualitative study identifed
the process through which managerial
coaches use coaching competencies
to improve their direct reports’ perfor-
mance. Eight participants with mana-
gerial experience representing four
organizations were interviewed and
presented cards with the 10 most fre-
quently cited competencies from mana-
gerial coaching literature for them to
arrange into a representation of their
coaching process. Findings revealed that
(a) participants used all of the compe-
tencies, (b) they used them daily, and
(c) each participant had a unique pro-
cess of using coaching competencies.
Three competencies were identifed by
the participants as overarching, foun-
dational, or most important: supportive
environment, communication, and lis-
tening. All eight participants indicated
that their success rate in coaching their
direct reports for performance improve-
ment was at or near 80% overall. This
article illustrates that competencies
can be efectively and successfully used
in various ways as part of a manager’s
coaching process.