8 INŻYNIERIA MATERIAŁOWA MATERIALS ENGINEERING ROK XXXVIII
The application of tumble finishing in surface preparation
process for deposition of TBC coatings
Sławomir Kotowski
1*
, Andrzej Nowotnik
1
, Jan Sieniawski
1
, Andrzej Butkiewicz
1
1
Department of Material Science, Rzeszow University of Technology, Rzeszow, Poland,
*
skot@prz.edu.pl
Thermal barrier coatings (TBC) are widely used for protection of turbine blades against aggressive thermomechanical and chemical degradation during
operation in hot section of aircraft engine. Quality and properties of TBC coating is strictly related to preparation of substrate material (grinding, and round-
ing off edges, polishing and cleaning). In the article, tumble finishing as method for surface preparation before deposition of thermal barrier coatings has
been described. The process was performed for different types of ceramic feedstock and base material in order to obtain homogeneous roughness. Tumbling
was carried out using centrifugal polishing machine. The research was divided into three stages. The first one consisted in investigation of the influence of
rotational velocity and water flow, on the course of tumbling process. Afterwards, proper type of ceramic feedstock has been selected. During the last stage,
ready-to-use recipes for polishing of samples made of for CMSX–4, Inconel® 718 and stainless steel 1.4016 were developed.
Key words: tumbling, tumble finishing, TBC, thermal barrier coatings, surface preparation.
Inżynieria Materiałowa 1 (215) (2017) 8÷14
DOI 10.15199/28.2017.1.2
© Copyright SIGMA-NOT MATERIALS ENGINEERING
1. INTRODUCTION
Taking into account the actual trends in aircraft engine design, in-
cluding constant shifting conditions in the hottest section of aircraft
engines towards higher temperature and more aggressive thermo-
mechanical and chemical conditions, it is imperative to apply mate-
rials characterized by highest mechanical properties and protective
coatings providing thermal insulation and chemical barrier for base
material. Increasing the operating temperature allows to improve
the engine efficiently and reduce fuel consumption and the emission
of carbon dioxide [1, 2]. This canalizes the research on modifica-
tion of engine design in order to improve the resistance to influence
of high temperature, oxidizing gases environment and mechanical
loads which are present in operating conditions.
In the article, the comprehensive procedure of manufacturing
thermal barrier coatings (TBC) is presented on the example of tur-
bine blade which is a component of hot section of aircraft engine.
The casting process of CMSX–4 blade, surface preparation process,
heat treatment, also the deposition processes of duplex-structure
thermal barrier coatings (TBC) with metallic interlayer (bond coat)
and external ceramic layer (top coat), were described.
The bonding and external layers were formed during, corre-
spondingly, chemical vapour deposition (CVD) and electron beam
physical vapour deposition processes (EB-PVD). Proper surface
characteristics is important in terms of coatings performance at high
temperature also in the presence of highly oxidizing gases.
2. MANUFACTURING OF SUBSTRATE MATERIAL
In order to obtain high temperature creep-strength, fatigue and
oxidation resistance, coating performance and retention of perfor-
mance in thin-walled configurations, CMSX–4 elements are manu-
factured using controlled alloy crystallization in vacuum which
provides single crystal structure [3]. In this form, CMSX–4 alloy is
widely used for elements of hot section of aircraft engines, e.g. tur-
bine blades. There are numerous methods applied to manufacturing
of single crystal castings. In Research and Development Labora-
tory for Aerospace Materials (Rzeszow University of Technology)
turbine blades are created using one of most popular casting tech-
niques — Bridgeman method (Fig. 1).
During the process, ceramic shell mould with liquid alloy is
shifted from the heating to cooling zone of the furnace. The chamber
assembly provides directional heat flow in the mould and thus di-
rectional solidification of casting. Application of spiral shaped grain
selector allows single grain to grow along direction close to [001]
axis. Vacuum furnace VIMIC 2 E – DS/SC, located in the Research
and Development Laboratory for Aerospace Materials, makes pos-
sible to establish precisely the values of process parameters, espe-
cially critical speed of mould withdrawal. At this stage, simulation
software is applied in order to predict casting microstructure and
optimize the casting process parameters (Fig. 2).
Fig. 1. Vacuum furnace VIMIC 2 E – DS/SC (ALD Vacuum Technolo-
gies GmbH) used for conducting casting processes by Bridgeman meth-
od. Research and Development Laboratory for Aerospace Materials [4]
Rys. 1. Piec próżniowy VIMIC 2 E – DS/SC (ALD Vacuum Technologies
GmbH) do prowadzenia procesu odlewania metodą Bridgemana. Uczel-
niane Laboratorium Badań Materiałów dla Przemysłu Lotniczego [4]