IJSER © 2016
http://www.ijser.org
Framework for Traffic Congestion Prediction
John FW Zaki
1
, Amr Ali-Eldin, Sherif E. Hussein, Sabry F. Saraya, Fayez F. Areed
Abstract— Traffic Congestion is a complex dilemma facing most major cities. It has undergone a lot of research since the early 80s in an
attempt to predict traffic in the short-term. Recently, Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) became an integral part of traffic research
which helped in modeling and forecasting traffic conditions. In this paper, two frameworks for traffic congestion prediction are proposed.
The first framework is based on NeuroFuzzy model which is well surveyed in traffic literature. The second framework is based on Hidden
Markov Models (HMM) which is rarely used in traffic prediction. The methods are used to define traffic congestion during morning rush
hours. The results of the two methods are compared.
The empirical evaluation is based on a UK dataset which is provided by the UK Department of Transport. The data is a year on year
statistics from 2009 to date and is available in a monthly ''.CSV'' files. It was collected using loop detectors and consolidated every 15
minutes for various links of the UK motorways.
Index Terms— NeuroFuzzy, Hidden Markov Models, Traffic Congestion Prediction, Empirical Evaluation
—————————— u ——————————
1 INTRODUCTION
raffic congestion has become an integral part of to-
day's modern life. It forces people to plan additional
time whether commuting to work, or traveling for
other purposes. It results in longer trip times, lower
air quality, and increased fuel wastage which in turn affect the
overall quality of life. Therefore, governments, universities,
and advanced research are attempting to tackle this problem
or at least ease its adverse effects using intelligent transporta-
tion systems (ITS). A major part of the ITS is traffic forecasting
based on realtime data to enable traffic decision makers to
make the right decisions.
There are various research methods used in the field of traffic
prediction such as deterministic methods, non-deterministic
approaches, and stochastic techniques. In this work, two
frameworks are proposed for traffic congestion prediction
during the morning rush hour. The first framework is based
on NeuroFuzzy technique which is well surveyed in traffic
literature. The second framework is based on HMM which is
rarely used in traffic prediction due to its complex nature. The
results of the two methods are compared.
The organization of this paper starts with a review perspective
of the recent research followed by the introduction of the
realtime dataset to be used in the empirical evaluation. Next,
the theory behind this research is discussed. Sequentially, the
results and discussions, and the concluding remarks are pre-
sented.
2REVIEW OF EXISTING TECHNIQUES
Short-term traffic forecasting is a challenging research op-
portunity. It attracts various researchers using a multitude of
methods to attempt forecasting different traffic parameters. In
a review paper, Vlahogianni et. al. [1] reviewed 10 challenging
research opportunities in the field of ITS focusing on forecast-
ing problem in ITS. Recently, Hashemi and Abdelghany [2]
developed a real-time traffic state prediction based on closed
loop rolling horizon. In their approach, some real-time system
deficiencies such as limited prediction accuracy, decision mak-
ing latency, and partial coverage of the managed area. In an-
other paper, ELHenawy and Rakha [3] detected congestion
using two-component mixture model. One is based on free-
flow speed distribution and the other is based on congestion
speed distribution. The model was calibrated and a threshold
was identified where congestion is detected if below the
threshold. Dong et. al. [4] proposed a spatio-temporal ap-
proach for freeway traffic flow prediction. Their approach
shows 5% results improvement over the standard autoregres-
sive integrated moving average (ARIMA) model. Yuan et. al.
[5] suggested a new model for traffic state estimation based on
Lagrangian-space and Kalman Filtering (KF). Their approach
provided more accurate numerical results compared to tradi-
tional methods in the same coordinate system. Tao et. al. [6]
developed a time-space threshold vector error correction (TS-
TVEC) model for short-term traffic state prediction. The statis-
tical model overcomes unknown structural changes in time
T
————————————————
1. Corresponding Author: John FW Zaki, (M .SC, M BA), is a lecturer assis-
tant at the Dept. of Computer and Systems. He is currently pursuing
PhD degree in Computer and Systems at Mansoura University, Faculty
of Engineering. E-mail: jfzaki@mans.edu.eg
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 7, Issue 5, May-2016
ISSN 2229-5518 1205
IJSER
brought to you by CORE View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk
provided by Leiden University Scholary Publications