© Copyright 2001 Physicians Postgraduate Press, Inc.
One personal copy may be printed
Ballenger et al.
24 J Clin Psychiatry 2001;62 (suppl 8)
epressive disorders and cardiovascular conditions
are closely interrelated. Compared with the general
Consensus Statement on Depression, Anxiety,
and Cardiovascular Disease
James C. Ballenger, M.D.; Jonathan R. T. Davidson, M.D.;
Yves Lecrubier, M.D.; and David J. Nutt, M.D., Ph.D.
(International Consensus Group on Depression and Anxiety);
and Steven P. Roose, M.D.; and David S. Sheps, M.D.
The International Consensus Group on Depression and
Anxiety held the meeting “Focus on Depression and Anxiety
Disorders in General Medicine,” October 7–8, 1999, in
Funchal, Madeira. The Consensus Meeting was supported by
an unrestricted educational grant from SmithKline Beecham
Pharmaceuticals.
Reprint requests to: James C. Ballenger, M.D., Medical
University of South Carolina, Department of Psychiatry and
Behavioral Sciences, 171 Ashley Ave., Charleston, SC 29425-
0742.
severe depression develop more severe cardiovascular dis-
ease, but there are data showing that patients with more
severe anxiety develop more severe cardiovascular dis-
ease. In a large study of male health care professionals,
Kawachi et al.
12
showed an association between panic
phobic symptoms and an excess risk of sudden cardiovas-
cular death.
Anxiety disorders, such as panic disorder and phobic
disorder, often start early in life and develop chronically.
They frequently lead to secondary depression and are a
risk factor for the development of cardiovascular disease
and for later sudden cardiac death. The presence of an anx-
iety disorder can bring people into a high-risk group at an
earlier age in their life.
Depression is not only a risk factor for cardiovascular
disease but is also a strong predictor of mortality in pa-
tients with manifest ischemic heart disease.
9
Among survi-
vors of acute myocardial infarction, the increased risk of
cardiovascular mortality is not restricted to patients with
major depression but also extends to those patients with
subsyndromal depressive symptoms. At 18 months after
myocardial infarction, the mortality rate is reported to be
the same in depressed patients who failed to meet full cri-
teria for major depression as in those meeting criteria for
major depression (17%).
13
Vulnerability to cardiovascular risk increases with age
in depressed patients, and it is most significant in the
population aged over 60 years, which is the most rapidly
growing segment of the world population. For example, a
significant and substantial excess risk of death, myocar-
dial infarction, or stroke in hypertensive patients aged
over 70 years has been associated with an increase in de-
pressive symptoms over time.
14
Also, elderly men (aged
over 70 years) newly diagnosed with depression are re-
ported to be almost twice as likely to have a cardiovascu-
lar event as men without a history of depression.
15
It is accepted clinical practice that primary care physi-
cians will consider risk factors for coronary artery disease
when evaluating patients aged over 40 years and will inter-
vene to decrease cardiovascular risk if they find hyperten-
sion, elevated cholesterol, or obesity. We feel strongly that
depression and anxiety should be included in this model.
D
population, individuals suffering from depression have an
increased risk of sudden cardiovascular death, and the risk
is highest in the presence of concomitant cardiovascular
disease.
1,2
Similarly, patients with cardiovascular disease
suffer from major depression more frequently than ex-
pected. More than 20% of subjects with angiographic evi-
dence of coronary heart disease have concomitant major
depression. Also, up to 20% of survivors of recent acute
myocardial infarction meet diagnostic criteria for major
depression, and the presence of depression is associated
with an increased 6-month mortality, compared with non-
depressed survivors.
3–8
At our consensus meeting on depressive and anxiety
disorders in general medicine, the International Consensus
Group on Depression and Anxiety reviewed depression,
anxiety, and the cardiovascular system from the perspec-
tives of both the cardiologist and the psychiatrist. This ar-
ticle sets forth our views on the management of comorbid
depression and anxiety in the cardiovascular patient on the
basis of the current state of knowledge and identifies areas
of further research.
DEPRESSION AND ANXIETY AS RISK FACTORS
FOR CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE
Good evidence indicates that clinical depression is an
independent risk factor for the development of coronary
artery disease,
9,10
and equally compelling evidence indi-
cates an association between anxiety and coronary artery
disease.
11
It is not yet known whether patients with more