Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy Systems 39 (2020) 4557–4576
DOI:10.3233/JIFS-200522
IOS Press
4557
Shipyard location selection based on fuzzy
AHP and TOPSIS
Abdullah T ¨ urk
a,
* and Murat
¨
Ozk¨ ok
a
Department of Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering, Karadeniz Technical University, Trabzon, Turkey
Abstract. The shipyard facility location selection (FLS) decision is a critical process that involves conflicting, qualitative,
and quantitative criteria. Multi-Attribute Decision Making (MADM) methods are used as a powerful tool to overcome this
complex problem. Today, using these methods in an integrated way, more accurate, efficient, and systematic results are
obtained in solving complex issues such as FLS, which contains an uncertain structure. This paper proposes a framework
for the weighting of criteria and ranking potential feasible locations (alternatives) using the combination of fuzzy analytical
hierarchy process (AHP) and fuzzy technique for order performance by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) methods. While
fuzzy AHP determines the importance values of the criteria by pairwise comparisons, fuzzy TOPSIS prioritizes the alternatives
using the relative weights obtained with Fuzzy AHP. The integration of these two techniques provides a robust approach
considering the results obtained for the shipyard FLS decision. The applicability of the proposed method is expressed in
Turkey by a case study of the shipyard FLS decision.
Keywords: Shipyard, location selection, fuzzy AHP, fuzzy TOPSIS
1. Introduction
The concept of globalization has emerged with the
advances in technique. The new world order brought
by this concept has caused the competition of firms
to increase with their rivals in their own country and
other countries. This increased competition made it
imperative that firms behave more rigorously in all
decisions they had to make to survive. Therefore, all
decisions should be supported by scientific data and
based on a systematic structure. Decision making is
a process that has different and non-commensurable
standards [1] and should be conducted meticulously
in such an era where competition is very high.
FLS is considered a significant problem that
requires a decision-making process and is defined as
∗
Corresponding author. Abdullah T¨ urk, Assistant, Naval Archi-
tecture and Marine Engineering, Karadeniz Technical University,
Surmene Faculty of Marine Sciences Camburnu/S¨ urmene,
S¨ urmene, 61600, Turkey. Fax: +90 462 377 80 58; E-mail:
abdullahturk@ktu.edu.tr.
the geographic location where a firm continues its
activities [2]. This location should enable the firm to
achieve low cost and high-profit rates and reach its
goals in the long run. Therefore, a correct FLS deci-
sion is a critical process for firms, and an incorrect
FLS decision causes inefficient use of raw materials,
inadequate transportation, and increased operating
costs [3].
FLS can occur due to many factors. The idea
of establishing a new facility is the most impor-
tant of these factors. The following factors are also
considered in the occurrence of FLS: technological
innovations, management changes, design changes
in the manufactured product or new product designs,
shift in demand, economic fluctuations, new machine
purchases, adverse effects of environmental problems
on the facility, and finally broader capacity needs [4].
Before FLS, a firm determines in which area it
will serve and what kind of products it will produce.
It then determines the criteria of a geographic loca-
tion, defined as all conditions and features required
ISSN 1064-1246/20/$35.00 © 2020 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved