Error analysis and auto correction of hybrid solar tracking system
using photo sensors and orientation algorithm
Junbin Zhang, Zhuojun Yin, Peng Jin
*
Peking University, Shenzhen Graduate School, Shenzhen, 518055, China
article info
Article history:
Received 15 October 2018
Received in revised form
20 April 2019
Accepted 3 June 2019
Available online 6 June 2019
Keywords:
Dual-axis hybrid solar tracking
Solar orientation
Installation deviation
Error correction
Daylight harvesting
abstract
In order to further improve the efficiency of daylight harvesting system, a high accuracy solar tracking
system is required. The tracking error is the combined result of various sources, such as the azimuth
rotational axis tilt, geo-positioning deviation, installation deviation, true north meridian deviation,
calculation error and mismatch of photo sensors, etc. In this paper, we designed a dual-axis hybrid
tracking system which uses GPS/BeiDou for geological location, photodiodes for closed loop tracking, and
orientation algorithm for open loop tracking. The difference of our calculated the solar hour angle,
altitude angle and azimuth angle to that of SOLPOS results are less than 1
. An initializing calibration is
proposed to correct the errors caused by the mismatch of photodiodes. The installation deviation, geo-
positioning error and true north meridian deviation for orientation algorithm are also analyzed and
corrected. This field test shows that the overall tracking accuracy of the system is improved after the
second dynamic compensation. The tracking system can be used in a low cost and small form factor solar
tracker with easy setup by providing geological location, orientation sensing and auto corrections for
weight and wind load if the photo sensors are positioned at the deflection location.
© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Solar energy is the ultimate renewable and clean way to solve
the increasing energy demand while reducing the CO
2
emission [1].
Solar energy has been harnessed in various forms such as PV, solar
thermal, concentration photovoltaics (CPV) and concentrated solar
power (CSP), etc [2]. Solar energy is not constant due to weather
and sun movement. However, tracking and concentrating the solar
flux can increase efficiency and power output for systems such as
CPV, CSP and daylight harvesting system [3e7]. Experiments by
Abdallah et al. [8] show that the productivity of a solar still using a
solar tracking system is increased by 22% compared with a fixed
solar still. Cruz-Perag on et al. [9] also conducted a similar experi-
ment on the solar power system, where the power generation of
photovoltaic tracking system could increased by 20%.
A higher concentration ratio requires a more accurate angular
tracking [10, 11]. The reliability and cost of tracking system are the
key factors in CPV and CSP markets. In low tracking accuracy
application such as a PV panel without concentration, an open loop
single axis tracking is sufficient, where the PV panel rotated auto-
matically [12, 13]. In order to reach concentration of over 100 suns,
the required tracking accuracy is in the range of ±0.5
to ±2
, where
dual axis tracking are needed [14]. A cost-effective and precise solar
tracking assembly require that tracker be able to withstand the
weight of all components and wind loads, and compensate any
system or random errors within certain tolerable bounds [15].
Theoretically, high-precision algorithms can accurately calculate
the solar position with negligible error [16]. However, various er-
rors arise in field application, and reduce the solar tracking accu-
racy [17]. The typical errors include the geo-positioning error,
installation error, time error, calculation error, mechanical error,
atmospheric refraction, weather, gravity bending, self-weight
structure deformation, wind load, etc. [15e18]. The geo-
positioning error is mainly reflected in the accuracy of obtaining
the geological longitude and latitude of location of the tracker. It
will directly affect the calculation of the solar position using the
solar trajectory tracking algorithm. Installation errors are the most
important sources of error in solar tracker, such as azimuth rota-
tional axis tilt, dual-axis nonorthogonality, reference position off-
sets, azimuth reference bias, elevation reference bias and true north
meridian [16, 17]. Atmospheric refraction and rainy weather tend to
* Corresponding author. Room E321A, Peking University Shenzhen Graduate
School, University Town, Xili, Nanshan District, Shenzhen, 518055, PR China.
E-mail addresses: zhangjunbin@pkusz.edu.cn (J. Zhang), 1701213738@sz.pku.
edu.cn (Z. Yin), jinpeng@pkusz.edu.cn (P. Jin).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/energy
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2019.06.032
0360-5442/© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Energy 182 (2019) 585e593