Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 213 (2015) 102–113
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/agrformet
Methane and carbon dioxide emissions from manure storage facilities
at two free-stall dairies
Richard H. Grant
∗
, Matthew T. Boehm, Bill W. Bogan
Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 19 September 2014
Received in revised form 11 June 2015
Accepted 12 June 2015
Keywords:
Carbon dioxide
Methane
Dairy
Waste
Emissions
Inverse Lagrangian
a b s t r a c t
Manure management by dairies is estimated to account for 6% of the greenhouse gas warming potential of
all agricultural emissions in the USA. Emissions methane (CH
4
) and carbon dioxide (CO
2
) were measured
from manure storage facilities at two Midwestern dairies (an Indiana lagoon and two Wisconsin basins).
The CH
4
concentrations were measured using photoacoustic infrared absorption spectroscopy and flame
ionization gas chromatography. The CO
2
concentrations were measured using photoacoustic infrared
absorption spectroscopy and non-dispersive infrared spectroscopy. Emissions were estimated using a
backward Lagrangian Stochastic model with on-site turbulence measurements.
The WI basins emitted more CH
4
and CO
2
than the waste lagoon in IN on an animal basis. Peak emissions
were episodic. Mean daily CH
4
emissions during the fall (October) from the WI basins and IN lagoon were
295 g hd
−1
d
−1
(374 g AU
−1
d
−1
) and 47 g hd
−1
d
−1
(59 g AU
−1
d
−1
), respectively. Mean CO
2
emissions dur-
ing the fall were 575 g hd
−1
d
−1
(374 g AU
−1
d
−1
) from the WI basins (October) and 107 g hd
−1
d
−1
(135 g
AU
−1
d
−1
) from the IN lagoon (September). Emissions were not resolvable (approximately emissions MDL)
when the storage area surface was frozen. Methane emissions contributed eight–ten times the radiative
warming potential of CO
2
(animal basis) at both dairies. Mean daily CO
2
-equivalent emissions from the
WI basins (IN lagoon) ranged from highs of 7.9 kg CO
2
-e hd
−1
d
−1
in October (2.6 kg CO
2
-e hd
−1
d
−1
in
September) to lows of 1.6 kg CO
2
-e hd
−1
d
−1
(0.4 kg CO
2
-e hd
−1
d
−1
) in December through January. Air
temperature was correlated with CH
4
and CO
2
emissions at the WI basin but not the IN lagoon. Wind
speed was weakly correlated with CH
4
emissions (but not CO
2
emissions) at both dairies. While weather
conditions were similar, the separation of solids prior to storage contributed to lower CH
4
and CO
2
emis-
sions and lower greenhouse warming potential per animal. Cooler climatic conditions decreased CH
4
and
CO
2
emissions as well as decreasing the mass ratio of CH
4
–CO
2
emissions.
© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Agriculture contributes approximately 8% of the greenhouse gas
(GHG) warming potential of emissions in the United State of Amer-
ica (USA) while the management of manure accounts for 13% of
that warming potential (EPA, 2014). Methane (CH
4
) and nitrous
oxide (N
2
O) are the reported GHG for the agricultural sector. Carbon
dioxide (CO
2
) is a small component of agricultural greenhouse gas
emissions that does not contribute to the greenhouse gas potential
for the sector since the carbon in the animal feed was originally
fixed by photosynthesis from the atmosphere. Although dairies
contribute almost 47% of the manure management equivalent CO
2
∗
Corresponding author. Fax: +1 765 496 2926.
E-mail address: rgrant@purdue.edu (R.H. Grant).
emissions of agricultural sources in the USA (EPA, 2014), there are
only a few studies to support these emission estimates.
Methane is biologically produced during anaerobic decompo-
sition of organic matter (Casey et al., 2006). Since these solids
are largely in the bottom of the lagoon or basin, most of the CH
4
is produced at the bottom of the storage facility. The optimum
temperature range for methanogenic archaea is around 35–45
◦
C
(similar to the core temperature of a cow), with a decrease in CH
4
production of approximately an order of magnitude as the temper-
ature decreases to 15
◦
C (Zeikus and Winfrey, 1976). Since methane
has a low solubility in water (NIST, 2012), as the production of
CH
4
increases, the CH
4
produced exceeds the capacity to be dis-
solved in water and forms bubbles attached to the solid surfaces
where the production occurs. Consequently, this results in the con-
centration of CH
4
in the bubbles to be much higher than that of
the liquid (Ni et al., 2009). As the bubbles rise through the lagoon
or basin, they either ‘boil’ at the open liquid surface or burst at
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.agrformet.2015.06.008
0168-1923/© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.