Catena 218 (2022) 106542
Available online 4 August 2022
0341-8162/© 2022 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Infltration and bulk density dynamics with simulated rainfall sequences
Francesca Todisco
a, *
, Lorenzo Vergni
a
, Alessandra Vinci
a
, Dino Torri
b
a
Department of Agricultural, Food and Environmental Sciences, University of Perugia, Borgo XX Giugno 74, 06121 Perugia, Italy
b
CNR-IRPI, Perugia, Italy
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Interrill
Infltration
Bulk density dynamics
Roughness dynamics
Porosity dynamics
Infltration dynamics
ABSTRACT
Experiments with simulated rain on interrill plots were set up (2016–2017) at the Masse SERLAB station
(42
◦
59
′
34
′′
N 12
◦
17
′
27
′′
E, Italy) to study the cumulative effects of the processes affecting the soil surface and the
top 5-cm soil layer under a series of rainfalls separated by a no-rain period of several days. The modifcations
were quantifed in terms of random roughness, bulk density (BD), porosity, and infltration dynamics. Each
experiment consists of an initial tillage and three rainfall events (intensity = 40 mm/h during wetting and 70
mm/h during runoff) in a silt-clay-loam with 51 % silt and 34 % and clay. The data confrm a quick and
considerable decrease in porosity (derived through BD data). Nevertheless, the decrease is not monotonic and
continuous; on the contrary, it is counteracted by an increase during the inter-rainfall period. When the porosity
behavior is plotted versus applied pressure (rainfall impacts), as in oedometer tests, then it suggests a behavior
on the verge of deterministic chaos with two attractors. The roughness behavior also shows a partial recovery
during the between-rains intervals, confrming the BD trends. Introducing the decrease in pore size and the total
porosity within a simple porous media hydraulic formula, it was possible to interpolate the infltration data. The
presence of the two BD attractors means that predictions can never be precise, unless the processes leading to the
recovery of porosity are studied in detail in order to generate algorithms that evaluate the soil’s recovery
behavior, which can be used in advanced infltration models. This study underlines that adequate data are
needed to generate algorithms that can evaluate the soil’s ability to recover and the total porosity between
successive rainfalls.
1. Introduction
Raindrop impact is considered the main factor in forming the soil
crust, as it detaches particles and soil aggregates, modifying the soil
surface structure and causing compaction. Tackett and Pearson (1965)
found an exponential increase in bulk density due to cumulative rain.
Farres (1978) found that the increase in seal thickness during rain was
related to the cumulative rain logarithm. Boiffn (1984) observed a
hyperbolic decrease in the upper soil layer porosity with an increase in
the time of exposure to rain. Mualem et al. (1990) ascribed the
maximum change in the bulk density at the surface to the rain kinetic
energy. Roth (1997) suggested that the exponential decay function
proposed by Mualem et al. (1990) better represents the initial stages of
surface compaction. By contrast, a sigmoidal function better describes
bulk density changes in the later stages of structural seal formation.
Bielders & Baveye (1995) linked clay eluviation and the thickness of the
“washed in” layer to rain kinetic energy by means of linear regressions.
In a study on the effects of raindrop impact on soil micromorphology
under various crop systems, Panini et al. (1997) found that most of the
reduction in macroporosity is due to the loss of elongated pores. They
developed a simple approach for linking the size reduction of elongated
macroporosity to causative factors through an exponential decay func-
tion in a quantitative, physically-based manner.
The sealing/crusting process causes a decrease in the infltration rate
and an increase in runoff and soil erosion (Duley and Kelly, 1939; De
Ploey, 1981), and, if disregarded, it may be harmful to both the natural
and the anthropic ecosystems. Besides the expected infltration rate
decrease due to soil void saturation (Philips, 1957; for stable pore system
networks), the destruction of aggregates seals the pores and adds a
further decrease in pore space and pore connectivity in the sealed layer,
as shown by many studies pioneered by Horton (1939). Sealing of soil
pores, which occurs as the frst step toward crusting, decreases infl-
tration rates rapidly and pronouncedly (Horton, 1939). Hence, it in-
creases runoff coeffcients. The interpolation curve, which is most often
used to describe the change in the infltration rate due to sealing, is a
negative exponential of time, which can be substituted by cumulated
rain, or by rainfall kinetic energy, with more or less empirical
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: francesca.todisco@unipg.it (F. Todisco).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Catena
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/catena
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2022.106542
Received 3 December 2021; Received in revised form 22 July 2022; Accepted 23 July 2022