Bifurcation analysis of continuous aerobic nonisothermal bioreactor for
wastewater treatment
Rigel V. Gomez-Acata
*
, Pablo A. Lopez-Perez
*
, Rafael Maya-Yescas
**
, Ricardo Aguilar-Lopez
*
*Department of Biotechnology & Bioengineering, CINVESTAV-IPN, No. 2508
D.F. Mexico (Tel: 55-5747-3800; e-mail: raguilar@cinvestav.mx).
** School of Chemical Engineering, Universidad Michoacana de San Nicolas de Hidalgo
Michoacan, Mexico (e-mail: rmayay@umich.mx)
Abstract: The petrochemical industry water effluents must be treated before their discharge to lakes,
rivers and the ocean so that activated sludge plants are used. It is of great importance to satisfy several
environmental regulations in order to achieve the lowest impact in the ecosystem. This paper explore the
behaviour of a wastewater treatment plant model of a petrochemical industry in order to define the optimal
operation conditions for the discharge of effluent under the safety regulations, furthermore risk operation
areas where stable and unstable equilibrium points existed are outlined.
Keywords: Water pollution, Dynamic behaviour, Limit cycles, Bifurcation analysis, Reactor modelling,
Stability analysis
1. INTRODUCTION
The complexity of the dynamics of biological and ecological
processes and their interaction with other systems offer many
challenges to control engineering. For example, many
bioprocesses involved in water treatment are operated
continuously; the complexity of these processes is related to
variety of microorganisms involved, variability of
environmental disturbances, large perturbations to feed flow
rate and uncertainties about composition of the incoming
wastewater; they are also nonlinear systems, which could
exhibit multiplicity of steady states and instabilities areas
(Ajbar and Gamal, 1997; Ibarra-Junquera et al., 2004; Ewart
et al., 2006; Femat et al., 2004; Gwaltney and Stadtherr, 2007;
Hess and Bernard, 2008; Lara-Cisneros and Femat, 2009).
Activated sludge treatment is a complex process where many
states and nonlinear relationships are involved, in addition
relationships among inputs and outputs in a bioreactor are also
complex (nonlinear and time varying) (Fujie et al., 1998;
Maqueda et al., 2006). Several studies about wastewater
treatment models are focused in their stability and dinamic
behaviour (by bifurcation analysis) ir order to investigated the
conditions for increasing the performance of the biological
system, or avoid risk areas during operation of the bioreactors,
examples of the above are the work of Volcke et al., 2010,
that constructing operating diagrams for the nitrification
process (comounly present in wastewater effluents) by two-
step biological conversion, they specified unstable and steady
state multiplicity zones and pointed out that the choice of a
kinetic structure implies a certain steady steate behaviour;
Jianqiang & Ray, 2000, studied the dynamic behaviour of two
coupled continuous stirred-tank reactors with recycle for
biological wastewater treatment when one of the reactors is
operated under self-sustained natural oscillations in order to
improve the reactor performance; Bertucoo et al., 1990
examined the stability and bifurcation characteristics of the
activated sludge reactors with solids recycle and showed the
existence of steady-state multiplicity for some range of
operating parameters; Ibrahim et al., 2006 described a model
bioreactor for an activated sludge process. The stability and
bifurcation characteristics of the model were investigated, the
bifurcation analysis of the model showed simple and complex
dynamic behaviour over a wide range of the model
parameters. The model exhibited a new interesting behaviour
(in some range of parameters) including four static limit
points (turning points) and two Hopf points, that cause
different kinds of stability characteristics ranging from
asymptotically stable equilibrium and hysteresis phenomen to
periodic and complex behaviour.
The objetive of bifurcation analysis is to characterize changes
in the qualitative behaviour of a mathematical model defined
by ODE´s and/or PDE´s by varying key parameters. In the
case of bioreactor operation is common to use the dilution rate
as a bifurcation parameter. Many important features as well as
potential limitations hard to find with simple simulations are
uncovered through this analysis (Zhang and Henson, 2001;
Garhyan et al., 2003)
Furthermore, this analysis can be used to find optimal
operating conditions and to avoid hazardous conditions for the
process (Namjoshi, Kienle, & Ranmkrishna, 2003).
The bifurcation occurs when one of the eigenvalues is close to
the axis of imaginary numbers in the complex plane. The
simplest bifurcations are associated when one of the
2012 IFAC Conference on Analysis and Control of Chaotic Systems
The International Federation of Automatic Control
June 20-22, 2012. Cancún, México
978-3-902823-02-1/12/$20.00 © 2012 IFAC 24
10.3182/20120620-3-MX-3012.00054