IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON BIOMEDICAL ENGINEERING, VOL. 52, NO. 10, OCTOBER 2005 1741
Implementation of a Water Compensator for Total
Body Irradiation
Paolo Gallina, Giulio Rosati*, and Aldo Rossi
Abstract—This paper presents the design, implementation, and
testing of an integrated system for improving dose homogeneity
in total body irradiation (TBI). TBI is a radiation therapy tech-
nique that consists in delivering a uniform X-ray dose to the en-
tire body of the patient. Because of variations in patient’s tissues
thickness and density, achieving a uniform dose over the entire
body is one of the major challenges in TBI. The system proposed
in this paper, whose main goal is to compensate for tissues hetero-
geneities, is made up of a translating bed, a linear accelerator, a
vision system for body thickness assessment, a dynamically con-
trolled water filter, and a main control unit. The water filter, placed
between the X-ray source and the patient, is made up of an array of
70 small water containers (cells). The water level in each cell is con-
trolled in real time, so as to modify the dose distribution both in the
transverse direction and in the longitudinal direction. A prototype
of the water filter system was implemented and tested, achieving
good results in terms of dose uniformity.
Index Terms—Level control, total body irradiation, water, X-ray
applications.
I. INTRODUCTION
T
OTAL body irradiation (TBI) is a radiation therapy tech-
nique employed in the treatment of patients suffering from
various hematological diseases. In particular, TBI is a necessary
component in patient conditioning before bone marrow trans-
plantation in the treatment of acute leukemia and other hemato-
logical diseases. Far from being a consolidated technique, TBI is
delivered in a variety of protocols, employing different facilities
and tools. Basically, every TBI protocol involves one or more
external X-ray sources to deliver a given radiation dose to the
entire body of the patient [1]. Unlike traditional radiotherapy,
which targets a specific area of the body, TBI must encompass
the entire body within the radiation field. A common way to ob-
tain this configuration consists in projecting an horizontal X-ray
beam over a long distance, the patient being placed within the
field in a standing, semi-upright, or side-lying position (an inter-
esting review about the different techniques employed to deliver
TBI can be found in [2], whereas translating-bed techniques are
referred to in the next paragraph). Since the whole dose is usu-
ally delivered among several fractions (from 6 to 12) that can
last up to 1 hour each plus up to 1 hour of setup time (this is
Manuscript received January 16, 2004; revised February 6, 2005. This work
was supported by University of Padua, Italy. Asterisk indicates corresponding
author.
P. Gallina is with the Department of Energetics, University of Trieste, 34127
Trieste, Italy (e-mail: pgallina@units.it).
*G. Rosati is with the Department of Innovation in Mechanics and Man-
agement, University of Padua, via Venezia 1, 35131 Padua, Italy (e-mail:
giulio.rosati@unipd.it; web: www.mechatronics.it).
A. Rossi is with the Department of Innovation in Mechanics and Manage-
ment, University of Padua, 35131 Padua, Italy (e-mail: aldo.rossi@unipd.it).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TBME.2005.855715
the case, for example, of the side-lying patient technique em-
ployed at the S. Bortolo Hospital of Vicenza, Italy), it is clear
that patients are forced to hold an uncomfortable posture for a
long time. Another major problem in performing an efficient
TBI therapy is that a uniform dose must be delivered to the en-
tire body. Local radiation absorption depends on tissue thick-
ness and density (i.e., on tissue equivalent thickness). For this
reason, care must be taken to deliver an adequate radiation dose
to thicker parts of the patient (such as pelvis) without overdosing
thinner parts (such as neck). In order to reach this goal, most
TBI protocols include the use of metallic or plastic shielding
blocks, placed between the patient and the source [2]–[6]. How-
ever, shielding block design, construction, and positioning is an
expensive and time-consuming procedure. Moreover, compen-
sation accuracy is not always satisfactory, being affected by pa-
tient’s movements during irradiation. As a result, the therapy
turns out to be not repeatable and not always effective.
In order to improve TBI, some new techniques have been de-
veloped in the last decades. One of the most revolutionary con-
sists in employing a translating unit to move the patient under
the radiation source. In this way, only a small part (a sort of
transverse slice) of patient’s body lies within the X-ray field
at a time: the unit is moved slowly below the gantry, that gen-
erates a vertical beam, while the patient comfortably rests in
supine or prone position on the translation bed [7], [8]. Correct
dose delivery is obtained by modifying in real-time the transla-
tion velocity, whose value is calculated by taking into account
some physical parameters such as patient’s local thicknesses
and density, beam geometry, and dose rate. It has been proven
that the translating unit technique, if compared to fixed-beam
techniques, provides better dose uniformity and makes shielding
blocks placement more accurate [9]. Moreover, translating-bed
procedures are comfortable for patient and allow placing the
patient closer to the X-ray source [10]. The main drawback of
this approach is that dose uniformity can be achieved only in
the translation direction. It is clear that, with the aim of im-
proving this technique, a tissue density and thickness compen-
sator must be introduced to achieve homogeneous dose distri-
bution in the transverse direction. Moreover, the compensator
should be suited to fit different patients in order to reduce setup
time and costs.
In this paper, we propose the use of a compensator based on
water as compensating medium. The compensator is completed
with a control system that dynamically changes the shape of
the water volume interposed between the X-ray source and the
patient. In this context, water-based compensation in TBI is a
promising technique that has been recently investigated. Shigeo
et al. carried out basic studies on a water compensator to be
placed between the patient and a 10-MV linear accelerator [11].
By means of phantom tests, they calculated the shape of the
0018-9294/$20.00 © 2005 IEEE