Response of juvenile tench (Tinca tinca L.) fed
practical diets with different protein contents and
substitution levels of fish meal by soybean meal
Vanesa Garc ıa, Jes us Domingo Celada, Roc ıo Gonz alez, Jos e Manuel Carral, Mar ıa S aez-Royuela
&
Alvaro Gonz alez
Departamento de Producci on Animal, Facultad de Veterinaria, Universidad de Le on, Campus de Vegazana s/n, Le on
24071, Spain
Correspondence: V Garc ıa, Departamento de Producci on Animal, Facultad de Veterinaria, Universidad de Le on, Campus de Vegaz-
ana s/n, 24071 Le on, Spain. E-mail: vgarm@unileon.es
Abstract
A basal practical diet for juvenile tench (Tinca
tinca) was formulated and elaborated to test sev-
eral protein contents and substitution possibilities
of fish meal (FM) by soybean meal (SBM) in a 90-
day trial with 5-month-old juveniles (30.54 mm
TL, 0.30 g W). A factorial design included nine
feeding treatments: three protein contents (50%,
40% or 30%) and three levels of replacement (0%,
25% or 45%) of FM protein by SBM protein. In
addition, a commercial carp feed was used as
reference. Final survival ranged from 98.2% to
99.4%. The 50% dietary protein with 0% or 25%
replacement and 40% dietary protein with 25%
replacement diets enabled higher growth
(P < 0.05) and lower FCR (P < 0.05) than the rest
of practical diets. Fish fed 50% dietary protein had
similar growth than those fed carp feed (63.8%
protein). Deformed fish averaged 1% for the practi-
cal diets and 87.6% for the carp feed. The basal
practical diet has showed to be feasible and levels
of 40–50% dietary protein with 25% replacement
of FM protein by SBM protein can be recom-
mended for juvenile tench aged 5–8 months.
Keywords: Tinca tinca, juveniles, practical diet,
dietary protein, fish meal, soybean meal
Introduction
Tench (Tinca tinca L. 1758), a freshwater fish
belonging to the family Cyprinidae, has a great
potential for aquaculture (Steffens 1995; Kamler,
Myszkowsky, Kami nski, Korwin-Kossakowski &
Wolnicki 2006; Wang, Min, Guan, Gong, Ren,
Huang, Zheng, Zhang, Liu & Han 2006; Wolnicki,
Myszkowski, Korwin-Kossakowski, Kami nski &
Stanny 2006). Originally occurring in the waters
of Europe and Siberia, today tench occurs in the
inland waters of all the continents (Freyhof &
Kottelat 2008). In Europe, tench has a history of
pond culture since the Middle Ages. However, the
intensification of culture techniques has recently
started. At present, tench is considered a promis-
ing new species for intensive culture, which
has drawn much attention from researchers and
farmers.
In natural habitats, tench are carnivorous, and
very small amounts of plant material found in the
alimentary tract have been swallowed incidentally
along with live preys (Kennedy & Fitzmaurice
1970). Gut content analyses show that juveniles
fed zooplankton and other small invertebrates
(Pyka 1996, 1997). At present, juveniles are
usually cultured in extensive or semi-extensive
systems in earthen ponds, where control and man-
agement of fish are difficult. Moreover, productions
are unpredictable, recording frequently high
mortality or slow growth. As consequence, the
major obstacle for the increase of tench production
is a deficit of young fish for stocking outdoor
ponds or open waters (Wolnicki et al. 2006;
Celada, Aguilera, Garc ıa, Carral, S aez-Royuela,
Gonz alez & Gonz alez 2009; Garc ıa, Celada, Carral,
S aez-Royuela, Gonz alez & Gonz alez 2010). For
these reasons, special attention is being paid to
find effective techniques for rearing juvenile tench
© 2013 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 28
Aquaculture Research 2015, 46, 28–38 doi: 10.1111/are.12154