J. Marine Sci. Appl. (2017) 16: 1-
DOI: 10.1007/s11804-017-1405-y
Optimization of Bottom-hinged Flap-type Wave Energy
Converter for a Specific Wave Rose
Hamed Behzad and Roozbeh Panahi
*
Department of Civil Engineering, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran 14115-116, Iran
Abstract: In this paper, we conducted a numerical analysis on the
bottom-hinged flap-type Wave Energy Convertor (WEC). The basic
model, implemented through the study using ANSYS-AQWA, has
been validated by a three-dimensional physical model of a pitching
vertical cylinder. Then, a systematic parametric assessment has
been performed on stiffness, damping, and WEC direction against
an incoming wave rose, resulting in an optimized flap-type WEC
for a specific spot in the Persian Gulf. Here, stiffness is tuned to
have a near-resonance condition considering the wave rose, while
damping is modified to capture the highest energy for each device
direction. Moreover, such sets of specifications have been checked
at different directions to present the best combination of stiffness,
damping, and device heading. It has been shown that for a real
condition, including different wave heights, periods, and directions,
it is very important to implement the methodology introduced here
to guarantee device performance.
Keywords: wave energy converter, bottom-hinged flap, power
take-off system, directional analysis, optimization
Article ID: 1671-9433(2017)02-0000-07
1 Introduction
1
Considering fossil fuel reserves reduction as well as global
warming issues, attention has been paid to renewable
energies although their technical and economic aspects still
need to be discussed in depth. Recently, wave energy, with an
average power density of 8 kW/m, compared to wind or solar
sources, with a maximum production capacity of 500 W/m
2
,
has received special attention (Flocard and Finningan, 2010)
although its level of technological readiness needs to be
justified. In recent years, numerous scientific and applied
research have been performed in this field with the aim to
design and optimize devices with an acceptable output. Such
devices, in terms of their distance from the coast, are
generally categorized into three main groups: shoreline,
nearshore, and offshore. Most research had been historically
focused on shoreline and offshore devices until Folly (2009)
introduced the concept of exploitable wave energy resource.
Despite the significant reduction of wave energy nearshore,
Folly (2009) discussed that exploitable energy does not vary
much if the effects of wave entrance into shallow waters is
Received date: 20-Jul-2016
Accepted date: 02-Dec-2016
*Corresponding author Email: rpanahi@modares.ac.ir
© Harbin Engineering University and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2017
taken into account (Folley and Whittaker, 2005). According
to Xiros and Dhanak (2016), the horizontal speed of water
particles sharply increases nearshore and strongly affects the
efficiency of surging Wave Energy Converters (WECs). It
has been proved in another research both theoretically and
experimentally that absorbed energy by a surging device
nearshore is directly related to the horizontal wave force
rather than the total wave energy (Folley et al., 2007). In
addition to the mentioned issues, these types of WECs are
less expensive to install and maintain compared to offshore
types. Additionally, in contrast to shoreline WECs, they do
not suffer from visual and environmental pollutions while
benefitting from higher energy levels due to wave breaking.
Caska and Finnigan (2008) investigated the hydrodynamic
performance of a cylinder hinged to the floor on average
depths. Finnigan (2010) continued the study with physical
models of the cylinder and investigated the effects of
damping and diameter on power capture. In the meantime,
Whittaker and Folly (2010) brought this idea into practice
and created a commercial model of the surging WEC called
Oyster. Zhao et al. (2013) of Zhejiang University optimized
the density and damping of this device for short-wave sea
states with wave periods lower than 6 s. Here it should be
noted that that flap-type WEC has been the subject of many
theoretical investigations (Renzi and Dias, 2013; Renzi and
Dias, 2015a). They have used physical models to verify
findings (Henry et al., 2015). Besides, it has been discussed
with more accurate or recently developed numerical models
(Wei et al., 2015; Wei et al., 2016; Wolgamot and Fitzgerald,
2015; Schmitt et al., 2016; Yeylaghi et al., 2016;
Tomey-Bozo et al., 2016; Pezzutto, 2016). Also, there are
lots of recent works discussing flap-type WEC in a farm
(Renzi et al., 2014; Renzi and Dias, 2015b, Gunawardane et
al., 2016), its Power Take-Off (PTO) mechanism (Bacelli et
al., 2015); its combination with wind energy in turbines
(Michailides et al., 2014), its extension over still water level
(Kamkar et al., 2013) or its degrees of freedom (Kurniawan
and Moan, 2012 ).
This study presents a simple new methodology to
investigate appropriate positioning of the apparatus and its
optimized PTO system in the presence of wave rose. The
study was performed in the Persian Gulf. The research
shows that a slight change in the stiffness of the structure
and thereby a change in its natural frequency has a drastic