Photoelectron Spectroscopy and DFT Calculations of Easily Ionized Quadruply Bonded
Mo
2
4+
Compounds and Their Bicyclic Guanidinate Precursors
†
F. Albert Cotton,*
,‡
Jason C. Durivage,
§
Nadine E. Gruhn,
§
Dennis L. Lichtenberger,*
,§
Carlos A. Murillo,*
,‡
Laura O. Van Dorn,
§
and Chad C. Wilkinson
‡
Department of Chemistry and Laboratory of Molecular Structure and Bonding, P.O. Box 30012, Texas A & M
UniVersity, College Station, Texas 77842-3012 and Department of Chemistry, Center for Gas-Phase Electron
Spectroscopy, The UniVersity of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona 85721
ReceiVed: March 23, 2006; In Final Form: April 17, 2006
A series of five bicyclic guanidinate compounds containing various combinations of five- and six-membered
rings and substituted alkyl groups have been shown by photoelectron spectroscopy to be easily ionized, with
the one having two six-membered rings and four ethyl groups being the most easily ionized. The corresponding
anions are capable of forming paddlewheel compounds having quadruply bonded Mo
2
4+
units which are also
easy to ionize. The most easily ionized compound is the ethyl-substituted Mo
2
(TEhpp)
4
complex which has
a broad first ionization band centered around 4.27 ( 0.03 eV and an ionization onset at the very low energy
of 3.93 ( 0.03 eV. Even the compound with ligands containing two five-membered rings, which favors a
long Mo-Mo separation because of the large ligand bite, has an ionization energy (4.78 eV) that is less than
those of well-known organometallic reducing agents such as (η
5
-C
9
Me
7
)
2
Co and (η
5
-C
5
Me
5
)
2
Cr.
Introduction
It has been established that guanidinate derivatives have an
extraordinary ability to lower oxidation potentials and in turn
stabilize higher oxidation numbers in compounds that feature
quadruply bonded units such as Cr
2
4+
, Mo
2
4+
, and W
2
4+
.
1
This
capacity is also manifested in the gas phase and indeed W
2
-
(hpp)
4
2
(hpp ) the anion of the bicyclic guanidine 1,3,4,6,7,8-
hexahydro-2H-pyrimido[1,2a]pyrimidine) is the most easily
ionized molecule known. The onset ionization energy of W
2
-
(hpp)
4
(3.51 eV)
2
is even lower than that of the cesium atom
(3.89 eV).
3
The dimolybdenum analogue, Mo
2
(hpp)
4
, has an
onset ionization that is only slightly higher (4.01 eV) but still
less than that of the francium and rubidium atoms.
2
When the noncyclic triphenylguanidinate anion is used to
bridge Mo
2
4+
units, stabilization of Mo
2
5+
and even Mo
2
6+
cores
is observed.
4
However, this noncyclic ligand is far less efficient
at stabilizing high oxidation states in dimetal units as shown
by the fact that the potential for the Mo
2
5+/4+
process is about
1.2 V more positive than for the hpp compound.
5
The reason for the ease of ionization of quadruply bonded
M
2
(hpp)
4
compounds is that the π electrons of the highly basic
guanidinate core strongly interact with the electrons in the M-M
δ bond
2a
thereby destabilizing the M
2
4+
core and favoring
oxidation to the relatively uncommon M
2
5+
and even rarer M
2
6+
species.
Because of such extraordinary properties of the M
2
com-
pounds with these ligands and also because of the general
interest in guanidinate ligands,
6
which have also been commonly
used to stabilize mononuclear compounds
7
many of which are
used in polymerization catalysis,
8
we decided to explore more
bicyclic guanidinates to determine how changes in the geometry
constraints of the fused-ring ligand system and/or addition of
electron-donating substituents affect the ability of the anions
to stabilize or destabilize charge in M
2
systems.
It should be noted that ligand tunability, the modification of
electronic structure to achieve a desired property of the
molecular system, has valuable applications in many areas of
science. Specifically, the ability to control the ease with which
an electron can be removed from a molecule is crucial for
electron-transfer reactions, catalysis, and materials applications.
9-13
We report here four bicyclic guanidinate ligands that have
never been used before in coordination chemistry along with
studies of some of their Mo
2
4+
species. In Figure 1, the ligand
at the top is hpp, the benchmark for comparison of the modified
ligands. The hpp anion has a 6,6 ring system with 12 hydrogen
atoms on the 6 ancillary carbon atoms. In the middle of the
figure are tbo and tbn. The first one, tbo, is the anion of 1,4,6-
triazabicyclo(3.3.0)oct-4-ene. It has a 5,5 ring system containing
8 hydrogen atoms on the 4 ancillary carbon atoms. The second
one, tbn, is the anion of 1,4,6-triazabicyclo(3.4.0)-non-4-ene,
and it has a 5,6 ring system with 10 hydrogen atoms on the 5
ancillary carbon atoms. The bottom of the figure shows TMhpp
and TEhpp. The former, TMhpp, is the anion of 3,3,9,9-
tetramethyl-1,5,7-triazabicyclo[4.4.0]dec-4-ene and has a 6,6
ring system with the 4 hydrogen atoms on the carbon atom
midway between the nitrogen atoms of each ring replaced with
methyl groups. The latter, TEhpp, which is the anion of 3,3,9,9-
tetraethyl-1,5,7-triazabicyclo[4.4.0]dec-4-ene, also has a 6,6 ring
system but with the 4 hydrogen atoms on the corresponding
carbon atoms replaced with ethyl groups.
It should be noted that as a key feature for tbo and tbn there
is a divergent angle between the bond directions from the
ligating nitrogen atoms relative to hpp, while for TMhpp and
TEhpp the alkyl groups have been inserted for the main purpose
of enhancing solubility of the Mo
2
(bicyclic guanidinate)
4
compounds and have no first-order effect on the bite. This is
†
Part of the special issue “Charles B. Harris Festschrift”.
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: cotton@tamu.edu
(F.A.C.); dlichten@email.arizona.edu (D.L.L.); murillo@tamu.edu (C.A.M.).
‡
Texas A&M University.
§
The University of Arizona.
19793 J. Phys. Chem. B 2006, 110, 19793-19798
10.1021/jp061820m CCC: $33.50 © 2006 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 05/24/2006