Landslides
DOI 10.1007/s10346-018-1017-x
Received: 9 March 2017
Accepted: 15 May 2018
© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany
part of Springer Nature 2018
Shinro Abe I Dinh Van Tien I Do Ngoc Ha I Takashi Hoshide I Tadashi Nishitani I
Toyohiko Miyagi
Topography and landslides in weathered granitic rock
areas—Hai Van landslide in central Vietnam
Abstract Many landslides occur every year during heavy rains at
the Hai Van Pass and surrounding area in central Vietnam, where
granitic rocks are distributed. As is common in granite areas, these
landslides often occur as small-scale flow-type and slump-type
landslides. However, several horseshoe-shaped loose slopes of
widths and lengths of 500 to 800 m, which incorporate these
landslides, are observed on slopes across the area. These topogra-
phies resemble those formed by past and present large-scale land-
slides. The presence of such a topography and the repeated
occurrences of landslides within this topography are rare in gran-
ite areas, where shallow flow-type landslides are generally fre-
quent. To understand the mechanism causing the landslides in
the Hai Van region, and as a support for future risk assessment,
the factors and processes leading to the formation of such a
topography and their relationship with these landslides must be
identified and assessed. This study investigated the history of past
landslide movement in the Hai Van Pass and surrounding area
through observations of drill cores and outcrops, and analysis of
the direction of remanent magnetism in the granitic rocks. Mineral
compositions, cracks, degrees of weathering, and topographic
shapes of the granitic rocks and their relationship to the landslides
occurring today were also investigated. The results of the study
reveal no variation in the direction of remanent magnetism in the
granitic rocks in the region that would indicate disturbance of the
ground due to a past large-scale landslide. No evidence of such an
event could also be found both in the drill cores and the rock
outcrops. Further, results of the analysis of cracks and weathering
pattern confirm that the topography of the region is affected by the
weathering of the granitic rocks that progresses in concentric
circles of various sizes. Thus, it can be concluded that these
topographies were not formed by a singular large-scale landslide
of the past, but rather by a composite of relatively shallow land-
slides occurring on the slope of dome structures unique to granite
areas, which are formed by differential weathering and denudation
regulated by cracks.
Keywords Vietnam
.
Hai Van landslide
.
Remanent
magnetism
.
Granitic dome
.
Weathered granite
Introduction
Many shallow landslides of either slump or flow type, with widths
and lengths of 30 to 200 m, occur every year on granitic rock
slopes in the Hai Van Pass and surrounding areas, located 10 km
north of the city of Da Nang, Vietnam (Fig. 1). The landslides that
occurred behind the Hai Van Train Station during a heavy rain
event in November 2007 destroyed railroad tracks and part of the
station and led to the temporary suspension of railroad transpor-
tation. In this region, there are major roads and railroads
connecting north and south Vietnam. Therefore, the damages
from these landslides had a profound impact on the transportation
and economy of the country.
On the slope behind the Hai Van Station, a horseshoe-shaped,
gentle-sloped topography of width and length of 800 m and
inclination of 10–15° is observed. Many landslides have recently
occurred in this topography. Similar topography can be found in
multiple locations on the slopes from Hai Van Pass to the coast
(Fig. 2), where features usually formed by a slump-type landslide
are displayed, such as steep cliffs at the head and on the sides of
the landslide, as well as zones of depression along the steep cliffs
(e.g., Cruden and Varnes 1992). However, the outlines of these
topographies are not very clear, and they may have been formed
by a large-scale pre-historic landslide.
The occurrences of large-scale landslides in granite areas have
been reported in the literature, such as the landslide in the
Muonglay area of northern Vietnam (Khanh 2009) and the ancient
landslide in the State of Arizona, America (Gootee 2008), but such
cases are rare. Landslides in a granite area generally occur as a
shallow flow-type landslide, usually triggered by heavy rain events
on a slope in which granite has been weathered to sand. An
example of this is the landslide in the Hiroshima region that
caused 76 casualties in 2014 (Wang et al. 2015).
The presence of a horseshoe-shaped gentle-sloped topography
is indicative of a large-scale, slump-type landslide, and many
recent landslides have occurred within such a topography around
the Hai Van Pass. As noted above, such cases are rare in granite
area. Therefore, it is important to identify the cause of formation
of such topography and the factors that cause landslides in this
topography in order to evaluate future risk, develop measures
against landslides, and identify the landslide mechanism in granite
areas. For convenience, in this paper, we refer to the large-scale
horseshoe-shaped gentle-sloped topography as Blarge-scale land-
slide topography^ regardless of its cause. Those landslides that are
occurring numerously in recent years within these large-scale
landslide topographies with widths and lengths of 30 to 200 m,
are referred to as Brecent landslides.^ Finally, the large-scale land-
slide topography behind the Hai Van Station is referred to as the
BHai Van landslide.^
The causes of formation of the large-scale landslide topography
observed in the granite area surrounding Hai Van Pass, together
with its relationship with recent landslides, are hypothesized to be
either one of the following:
(1) The large-scale landslide topography is the trace of a past
large-scale landslide, and the recent landslides occur on a
mass that moved in the past and stopped on the slope.
(2) The topography is formed by differential weathering
unique to granite, and recent landslides occur within this
topography.
Landslides
Technical Note