169
20%.
1,2
However, less is known about
the longer-term outcome at school age.
There is a high prevalence of learning
and behavior problems and early
school failures, even in preterm chil-
dren who are neurologically normal.
3,4
Both biological and social factors deter-
mine these suboptimal outcomes.
3,5,6
Medical factors may be less critical and
social factors more influential as the
child develops.
7,8
Social factors found to
be associated with school-age outcomes
tend to be “distal” markers of social risk
such as parental race, education, mari-
tal status, and income. Moreover, few
studies have assessed the family envi-
ronment in which the preterm child is
reared.
8
See editorial, p 153.
We describe a longitudinal, prospec-
tive follow-up to age 10 years of a re-
gional cohort of children born at <32
weeks’ gestational age and a socioeco-
nomically matched term control group
born in the mid 1980s. The effect of the
child’s family composition, extent of in-
volvement of each biological parent in
child rearing, and changes in family res-
idence on school performance were ex-
amined. We anticipated that the preterm
children would have poorer cognitive
and academic performance and more
behavior problems than would term
control subjects. Further, we hypothe-
sized that in preterm children, environ-
mental factors would be stronger pre-
dictors of school performance than
Improvements in perinatal care during
the past 2 decades have resulted in sig-
nificantly increased survival for very
premature infants. This trend has gen-
erated substantial interest in the sub-
sequent developmental outcome of re-
Impact of family structure and stability on academic
outcome in preterm children at 10 years of age
Steven J. Gross, MD, Barbara B. Mettelman, PhD, Timothy D. Dye, PhD, and Terri A. Slagle, MD
cent preterm survivors. A large body
of evidence suggests that early neu-
rodevelopmental outcome is favorable,
with the proportion of children surviv-
ing with severe cognitive or neurologic
disorders remaining at about 10% to
From the Departments of Pediatrics and Psychiatry, State University of New York, Upstate Medical University,
Syracuse, New York; Department of Community and Preventive Medicine, University of Rochester, Rochester, New
York; Department of Pediatrics, California Pacific Medical Center, San Francisco.
Submitted for publication Mar 31, 2000; revisions received Aug 2, 2000, Sept 12, 2000, and Sept
25, 2000; accepted Sept 25, 2000.
Reprint requests: Steven J. Gross, MD, Crouse Hospital, Department of Neonatology, 736
Irving Ave, Syracuse, NY 13210.
Copyright © 2001 by Mosby, Inc.
0022-3476/2001/$35.00 + 0 9/21/111945
doi:10.1067/mpd.2001.111945
NHIS National Health Interview Survey
OR Odds ratio
Objective: To compare school performance at age 10 years in a cohort of
extremely preterm children and term control subjects and to examine the
impact of family composition and stability on performance.
Study design: Prospective, longitudinal follow-up from birth to 10 years
of age of a regional cohort of children born at 24 to 31 weeks of gestational
age and sociodemographically matched term control subjects. Family
composition, extent of parental care giving, and family moves were tracked
sequentially. At 10 years, academic achievement and school performance
were ascertained for 118 of 125 (94%) preterm survivors and 119 of 125
(95%) term children.
Results: Term children were more likely to demonstrate optimal school
outcome (appropriate grade level without additional classroom assistance)
than were preterm children (odds ratio 3.4, 95% CI 1.9-6.0). Medical
complications related to prematurity had little impact on school outcome.
Among preterm children, optimal school outcome was significantly
associated with increased parental education, child rearing by 2 parents
(regardless of marital status), and stability in family composition and
geographic residence over 10 years. These environmental influences
were less pronounced among term control subjects.
Conclusion: Although preterm children performed less well in school than
term children, family factors were stronger predictors of school perfor-
mance than were perinatal complications. (J Pediatr 2001;138:169-75)
ORIGINAL ARTICLES