Abstract This study compares four sample dissolution
methods for Boron determination in two National Institute
of Standard and Technology (NIST) botanical Standard
Reference Materials (SRMs) and three Agriculture
Canada/NIST RMs, each having a reference (certified or
best estimate) B concentration. The dissolution treatments
consisted of: 1) dry ashing at 500° C, 2) wet digestion with
HNO
3
+ H
2
O
2
, 3) extraction with hot HNO
3
and 4) closed
vessel microwave dissolution. The samples were spiked
before and after imposing dissolution treatments to study
B recovery by inductively coupled plasma mass spectro-
metric (ICP-MS) analysis. Microwave digests of NIST SRM
1515 and some in-house RMs were also used to compare
the B values of ICP-MS and ICP-AES (atomic emission
spectrometry). While all three digestion methods (dry ash-
ing, wet ashing and microwave) dissolved botanical sam-
ples, only the microwave method worked well for animal
tissues. In terms of B values in these materials, there was
no significant difference among the three digestion treat-
ments. Near 100% recovery of B spiked before and after
the sample dissolution indicates that there may not be a
significant loss of B during the dissolution process used in
this study. Extraction with hot HNO
3
was as effective as
the three digestion treatments, and B values for this method
agreed well with reference values. For the botanical mate-
rials studied, the B values determined by ICP-AES were
not significantly different from ICP-MS values. This study
shows that a simple, time and labor efficient hot HNO
3
ex-
traction is as effective as other digestion/dissolution meth-
ods for quantitative B recovery from biological materials.
Introduction
Boron is an essential element for plants [1] and its defi-
ciency as well as toxicity threaten crop productivity in
many areas [2]. Though the essentiality of B for animal is
not yet fully established [3, 4], there is growing evidence
that it may have a metabolic role in human and animal nu-
trition [5, 6]. Excess of B in food products and drinking
water is considered harmful for health [7]. Radiobiologi-
cal destruction of tumor tissue by Boron Neutron Capture
Therapy (BNCT) involves administering
10
B to diseased
tissues followed by irradiation with slow neutrons [8].
This technique requires targeting of
10
B to appropriate tis-
sues and precise monitoring of B concentrations in tumor
and surrounding tissue samples. Therefore, a method with
high precision and low detection limit is required to deter-
mine the quantity and the isotope composition of B in bio-
logical materials.
Analyte introduction in an aqueous liquid phase is con-
ventient for most analytical instruments. Boron present in
biological materials is brought into the liquid phase either
by destroying the sample matrix or extracting it with some
solvents. The sample matrix may be destroyed by fusion,
wet or dry ashing and microwave dissolution methods.
The closed-vessel (high pressure) microwave dissolution
method is fast and overcomes contamination and volatiliza-
tion problems of open-vessel methods. However, high-
pressure methods may be hazardous due to the danger of
explosion [9, 10]. Boron contamination and leaching of B
from borosilicate glass digestion vessels may increase the
B values [9] which may explain the higher recovery of B
in wet digestion compared to the microwave dissolution
method found by Bañuelos et al. [11]. Boron extraction
with dilute acids also overcomes contamination and vola-
tilization problems without dealing with strong acids and
high pressure.
Boron may be analyzed colorimetrically or by absorp-
tion, emission or mass spectrometry. Several colorimetric
methods which make use of reagents such as azomethine-
H, carminic acid, curcumin, dianthrimide, methylene blue
or quinalizarine, have been used for B analysis [12]. All
spectrophotometric methods however, have high limits of
detection (LOD) and suffer from matrix interferences
[13]. The azomethine-H method, which has been heavily
used, may not be suitable for B determination in micro-
A. M. S. Nyomora · R. N. Sah · P. H. Brown ·
R. O. Miller
Boron determination in biological materials
by inductively coupled plasma atomic emission
and mass spectrometry: effects of sample dissolution methods
Fresenius J Anal Chem (1997) 357 : 1185–1191 © Springer-Verlag 1997
Received: 13 June 1996 / Revised: 17 September 1996 / Accepted: 19 September 1996
ORIGINAL PAPER
A. M. S. Nyomora · R. N. Sah () · P. H. Brown · R. O. Miller
Department of Pomology, University of California, Davis,
CA 95616, USA