Acta Universitatis Wratislaviensis • No 3869
Literatura i Kultura Popularna XXIV, Wrocław 2018
Kamila Żyto
ORCID: 0000-0003-2822-8341
University of Łódź
Detours of absurdity: Coen brothers’ Fargo in
the noir melting pot of genre patterns
Keywords: flm noir, flm history, flm genres, cinema of Coen brothers
Słowa kluczowe: flm noir, historia flmu, gatunki flmowe, kino braci Coen
The long-lasting debate over whether flm noir should be seen as a genre,
a cycle or a tendency in the history of cinema remains unsettled. No defnitive
solution has been found, nor any consensus reached, owing to the fact that the
flm noir phenomenon is particularly complex and convoluted. Much of the debate
revolves around questions of approach and genre. But many movies, both those
released in the 1940s and 1950s (the classical period) and those released in the
following decades (the neo-noir, or postclassical, period), do not obviously ft
any genre pattern or other ordering scheme. The diversity among flms that are
now unquestionably classifed as noir, provokes controversy and raises numerous
questions. What does Sunset Boulevard (dir. Billy Wilder, 1950) have in common
with The Killers (dir. Robert Siodmak, 1946)? The frst one is simultaneously
a crime story, melodrama and horror. The second one is, without a doubt, a gang-
ster movie. Do all noir flms really constitute a single genre? I will leave this
question unanswered, as to support any of the various opinions about the generic
identity of flm noir is not the main aim of this paper.
1
From my perspective, there is little utility in joining this on-going debate, which
has reached a standstill some time ago. Therefore, I will make no attempt to prove
that either flm noir is one of popular culture’s most recognizable genres, or that it
is a historically restricted and determined tendency. Rather, flm noir, at its core, is
1
Magdalena Kempna-Pieniążek’s monograph on neo-noir cinema identifes nine different
approaches to the problem of defning noir. See: M. Kempna-Pieniążek, Neo-noir: Ciemne zwierciadło
czasów kryzysu, Katowice 2015, pp. 20–21.
DOI: 10.19195/0867-7441.24.4
Literatura i Kultura Popularna 24, 2018
© for this edition by CNS