Reversible Vertical Gaze Palsy in Sodium Valproate Toxicity
W
e read with interest the report on corticobasal syn-
drome by Rajagopal et al (1). At times, this neuro-
degenerative disorder may lead to vertical gaze palsy. We
evaluated a patient with valproate toxicity and hyperammo-
nemia and reversible vertical gaze palsy.
A 56-year-old man presented with progressive unsteadi-
ness, drowsiness, and cognitive decline for the past 6 months.
Twenty-five years previously, he was involved in a traffic
accident and was in coma for 2 weeks. Subsequently, he
made partial recovery with recurrent nocturnal generalized
tonic-clonic seizures. He was changed to monotherapy with
400 mg of sodium valproate twice daily for 6 months. The
patient’s relatives noted progressive drowsiness and decline in
cognition since the treatment was started. His general health
was otherwise excellent, and his last seizure occurred 3 weeks
before our evaluation.
On physical examination, the patient needed support to
stand and walk. He was drowsy with hypophonic and
dysarthric speech. Extraocular movements revealed marked
limitation of upward and downward gaze for both saccades and
pursuit with preserved horizontal gaze (see Video 1, Supple-
mental Digital Content 1, http://links.lww.com/WNO/A64).
Vestibulo-ocular reflex was preserved, but convergence was
absent. Pupils were of normal size and reactive to light. Motor
examination showed bradykinesia, rigidity, bilateral postural
tremors of hands, and positive pull test. He walked with short
steps, moderate stoop, and wide-based gait. His tendon reflexes
were brisk, and plantar responses were flexor. Sensory exami-
nation was normal.
Complete blood count, renal function tests, profiles of
glucose, sodium, potassium, calcium, and thyroid, thyroid
antibodies, and B12 levels were normal. Venereal disease
research laboratory testing and HIV testing were normal.
Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed diffuse cerebral
atrophy and bifrontal gliosis. There were no imaging signs
of atypical Parkinson syndromes. Electroencephalography
showed diffuse mild slowing of background activity of 6–7
Hz theta suggestive of mild diffuse encephalopathy.
His plasma ammonia level was 194 mmol/L (normal,
11–32 mmol/L) with valproic acid level of 109 mg/mL (ther-
apeutic range, 50–100 mg/mL). Sodium valproate was discon-
tinued, and 1,000 mg of levetiracetam twice a day was started.
Four days later, vertical gaze for both saccadic and pursuit
eye movements had markedly improved (see Video 2, Supple-
mental Digital Content 2, http://links.lww.com/WNO/A65).
Significant improvement also was noted in his rigidity, brady-
kinesia, and postural imbalance. One week later, he was walk-
ing independently.
Partial or total gaze palsy has been described with
exposure to phenytoin (2), phenobarbitone (3), and carba-
mazepine (4). Selective upward gaze palsy has also been
described in phenobarbitone poisoning (3). To our knowl-
edge, vertical gaze palsy in valproate intoxication has not
been reported. In our patient, complete recovery of upward
gaze palsy within few days of stopping valproate strongly
suggests a causal relationship. Our patient also had features
of parkinsonism, which showed a significant improvement
after stopping the medication (5). We did not rechallenge
the patient with valproate.
The centers for control of vertical gaze are located in the
premotor structures of the midbrain, namely, the rostral
interstitial nucleus of the medial longitudinal fasciculus and
the interstitial nucleus of Cajal. These areas have abundant
gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) receptors (6). In the in-
terstitial nucleus of Cajal in macaque monkey, medium-sized
and large GABAergic neurons have been identified projecting
contralaterally to the superior oblique and inferior rectus
motoneurons and presumably the contralateral interstitial
nucleus of Cajal as well. These commissural GABAergic pro-
jections are well suited to inhibit the superior oblique and
inferior rectus motoneurons and premotor down-burst-tonic
neurons during upward eye movements (7).
Valproate is a well-known GABAergic drug that
facilitates glutamic acid decarboxylase, an enzyme re-
sponsible for GABA synthesis. At high concentrations,
valproate also blocks GABA transaminase in the brain,
preventing degradation of GABA. The deactivation of
vertical burst neurons by the GABA agonist action of
valproate may explain the selective vertical gaze palsy as
a result of valproate toxicity (8).
Sarma Gosala Raja Kukkuta, MD, DM
Meghana Srinivas, MBBS
Nadig Raghunandan, MD, DNB
Mathew Thomas, MD, DM
Arvind Prabhu, MD
Mary Laly, MBBS
St. John’s Medical College Hospital,
Bangalore, Karnataka, India,
grk_sarma@yahoo.com
Supplemental digital content is available for this article.
Direct URL citations appear in the full text and are
provided in the HTML and PDF versions of this article on
the journal's Web site (www.jneuro-ophthalmology.com).
The authors report no conflicts of interest.
202 Letters to the Editor: J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2013; 33: 202-207
Letters to the Editor
Copyright © North American Neuro-Ophthalmology Society. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.