FOCUS: MEASURING EXPERIENCE
Instrument Development and Validation for Conservation Learning:
A Tool for More Rigorous Research and Evaluation
FRAN MAST , LEI ZHAO , AND LINDSAY MALDONADO
Abstract Modern zoos and aquariums position themselves as sites of conservation learning experiences.
With a mantle of economic and public accountability, zoos and aquariums need to understand and promote
conservation learning and its related components. While a great deal is known about conservation learning
generally, less is known about how visitor experiences in zoos and aquariums impact conservation learning
during a visit. This article outlines the need for more rigorous measurement tools for conservation learning
in informal learning settings and provides an overview of Shedd Aquarium’s work to validate an instrument
that reliably and accurately measures aspects of conservation learning in the context of zoo experiences.
Initial trends and limitations associated with this validated tool are described. An overview of future
research is outlined as are implications for future use of this tool by practitioners and researchers.
BACKGROUND
Conservation Learning in Zoos and
Aquariums in an Era of Accountability
Zoos and aquariums (henceforth zoos) have
taken on multiple, sometimes simultaneous
identities throughout their history. The earliest
zoos were primarily private sites of scientific
study (Ballantyne et al. 2007). A need for fund-
ing soon shifted, at least in part, the focus of
these early zoos and aquariums to that of enter-
tainment and leisure (Ballantyne et al. 2007).
While certain institutions and individuals were
early advocates, it is only within the last half
century that zoos have collectively taken on con-
servation as a core value (Fraser and Wharton
2007). Moreover, as Ballantyne et al. (2011b)
point out, conservation and sustainability
education are an increasingly important goal of
modern eco-tourism sites like zoos.
Today, zoos position themselves as impor-
tant purveyors of conservation learning experi-
ences (Ballantyne and Packer 2016; Ballantyne
et al. 2007; Tribe and Booth 2003). A recent
study of international zoo leadership, described
intended educational outcomes of their institu-
tions as relating to conservation awareness, con-
nectedness and action (Johnson et al. 2016).
The World Association of Zoos and Aquariums
(WAZA) further positions zoos as being
uniquely suited to influence visitor behavior
toward an ultimate conservation learning goal
of pro-environmental behavior (Barongi et al.
2015). Studies also show that zoo visitors gener-
ally think zoos play an important role in conser-
vation education; and suggest that visitors are
supportive of zoos promoting conservation
Fran Mast M.Ed. (fmast@sheddaquarium.org) is Research and Evaluation Associate at Shedd Aquarium in Chi-
cago, Illinois, United States. Lei Zhao, Ph.D. (kzhao@psionline.com) is Associate Psychometrician of PSI Services
LLC working in Olathe, Kansas, United States, formerly Senior Research and Evaluation Associate at Shedd
Aquarium in Chicago, Illinois, United States. Lindsay Maldonado M.S. (lmaldonado@sheddaquarium.org) is Direc-
tor, Research and Evaluation at Shedd Aquarium in Chicago, Illinois, United States and is a doctoral student at
Loyola University Chicago, Illinois, United States.
© 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. 367
Volume 61 Number 2 April 2018