147 ISSN 1462-2416 10.2217/PGS.13.186 © 2014 Future Medicine Ltd
Pharmacogenomics (2014) 15(2), 147–155
ReseaRch aRticle
Association between migraine and ACE gene
(insertion/deletion) polymorphism: the BioBIM study
Migraine is the third most common and the
seventh most disabling disease in the world [1].
However, this disease appears to be considerably
underestimated in regards to frequency, diagnosis
and therapy [2]. The pathogenesis of migraine has
seen, over time, a number of alternate theories
including vascular, neuroactive and vasoactive
substances, alteration of cortical electrical activ-
ity or modulation of immune system involve-
ment, refecting the fact that the problem is still
far from being fully elucidated [3]. It is therefore
evident that the identifcation of genetic factors
related to headache offers the possibility of a
broader understanding of the problem, regard-
less of the pathogenic mechanisms responsible.
Owing to the signifcant vascular involvement
in migraine pathophysiology, some authors have
considered genes that encode enzymes affecting
the vascular system and causing changes in blood
fow as candidates for genetic factors involved in
migraine susceptibility.
The angiotensin I-converting enzyme (ACE)
(ENZYME entry: EC 3.4.15.1) is a dipeptidyl
carboxypeptidase expressed in vascular endothe-
lial cells and other tissues. It plays an important
role in blood pressure regulation and electro-
lyte balance by hydrolyzing angiotensin I into
angiotensin II, a vasopressor and aldosterone-
stimulating peptide [4]. ACE is also able to inac-
tivate potent vasodilators such as bradykinin
and substance P [5], thus modulating vascular
tension and blood pressure [6,7].
The ACE gene (OMIM #106180) presents
with an intron 16 insertion (I) or deletion (D)
polymorphism of the 287 bp Alu repeat sequence,
resulting in three genotypes (D/D, I/D and I/I)
[7]. This polymorphism is directly related to serum
ACE levels, resulting in higher, intermediary and
lower levels in the subjects carrying D/D, I/D
and I/I genotype, respectively [6,7]. Several studies
have suggested a positive association between the
ACE-D allele and cardiovascular diseases [8–10].
Owing to the signifcant vascular involvement
in migraine, several authors have considered the
ACE gene as a candidate genetic factor involved
in migraine susceptibility; however, to date, the
studies investigating the association between the
ACE D/I polymorphism and migraine are contro-
versial and contradictory (SUPPLEMENTARY TABLE 1; see
www.futuremedicine.com/doi/suppl/10.2217/
pgs.13.186). Several studies showed that ACE
D/D genotype increases the risk of migraine
with aura (MwA) [6,11,12], migraine without aura
(MwoA) [13,14], and/or their combination [4].
Other authors found a correlation between ACE
D/D genotype and the frequency of migraine [9]
or suggested a protective effect against migraine
in male patients [7]. Additionally, one study dem-
onstrated that subjects with the ACE I/I genotype
may be protected from migraine development [5].
Aim: In the present case–control study, we investigated the correlation between the common ACE
insertion/deletion (I/D) polymorphism and migraine. Materials & methods: Genotyping of the ACE I/D
variant was performed in 502 Caucasian patients with migraine and 323 age-, sex- and race/ethnicity-
matched healthy controls. We investigated associations between ACE genetic variants and sociodemographic
and/or clinical features of migraineurs. Results: We found a significant association between ACE
insertion/insertion (I/I) polymorphism and lower use of pharmacological prophylaxis in migraine patients
with aura and in those with chronic migraine. Moreover, ACE I/I polymorphism was significantly more
common in migraine patients with aura who had a negative family history of migraine. Conclusion: Our
data suggest that although the ACE I/D polymorphism is not a direct risk factor for migraine, the ACE I/I
genotype may influence the clinical feature of this disease being associated with reduced use of prophylactic
agents in patients with migraine with aura and in those with chronic migraine.
Original submitted 5 June 2013; Revision submitted 16 September 2013
KEYWORDS: ACE I/D polymorphism n genetics n migraine n pharmacological
prophylaxis
Rafaele Palmirota
‡1
,
Piero Barbant
‡2
, Giorgia
Ludovici
1
, Maria Laura
De Marchis
1
, Cristano
Ialongo
3
, Gabriella
Egeo
2
, Cinzia Aurilia
2
,
Luisa Fof
2
, Pasquale
Abete
4
, Antonella Spila
1
,
Patrizia Ferroni
1
, David
Della-Morte*
1,5
&
Fiorella Guadagni
1
1
Interinsttutonal Multdisciplinary
BioBank (BioBIM), Department of
Advanced Biotechnologies
& Bioimaging, IRCCS San Rafaele
Pisana, Rome, Italy
2
Headache & Pain Unit, Department
of Neurological, Motor & Sensorial
Sciences, IRCCS San Rafaele Pisana,
Via Della Pisana 235, Rome 00163, Italy
3
Department of Internal Medicine,
University of Rome ‘Tor Vergata’,
Medicine & Surgery, Via Montpellier, 1,
Rome 00133, Italy
4
Department of Translatonal Medical
Sciences, University of Naples Federico
II, Napoli 80131, Italy
5
Department of Systems Medicine,
University of Rome ‘Tor Vergata’,
Medicine & Surgery, Via Montpellier, 1,
Rome 00133, Italy
*Author for correspondence:
david.dellamorte@sanrafaele.it
‡
Authors contributed equally
part of
For reprint orders, please contact: reprints@futuremedicine.com