Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Hydrology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jhydrol
Research papers
Mining activity impacts on soil erodibility and reservoirs silting: Evaluation
of mining decommissioning strategies
Tommaso Pacetti
⁎
, Marco Lompi, Claudio Petri, Enrica Caporali
University of Florence, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Italy
ARTICLE INFO
This manuscript was handled by Marco Borga,
Editor-in-Chief
Keywords:
Land use change
Hydrosedimentological modelling
Swat
Soil erodibility
Reservoirs silting
Mining site decommissioning
ABSTRACT
This study focuses on the nexus between coal mining and water storage, analyzing the strategies to reduce the
negative efects of exhausted/abandoned mining sites on catchments where water reservoirs are located.
Sediment management represent a key point to promote sustainable water resources development and it is
strictly connected with the proper management of land use change, especially in the areas devoted to mining
activities. The presence of a reservoir represents a major challenge because these structures are threatened by the
rapid loss of storage volume due to excessive sedimentation.
The case of San Cipriano reservoir in central Italy represents an ideal set to explore the efects of mining on
water storage because it is located at the outlet of a catchment strongly infuenced by one of the most important
lignite mine in central Italy. The Soil Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) is used to evaluate diferent scenarios of
mine decommissioning, aiming at supporting the identifcation of the best strategies to avoid reservoir sedi-
mentation. Two scenarios of environmental restoration of the mining area are evaluated. In the frst case, the
ongoing reforestation with native plants like oaks and deciduous trees is analyzed. In the second scenario the
authors focus on the evaluation of a wider landscape restoration project (including reforestation and river bodies
rehabilitation) recently drafted by local institutions.
The results provide a quantitative evaluation of the efectiveness of the proposed strategies in reducing the
impacts of existing mining sites from a hydrological perspective. In particular, the analyzed scenarios show that
aforestation and river restoration lead to a strong reduction of sediment yield while downward trend occurred
for water yield.
1. Introduction
Coal-based power plant represented one of the pillars of the Italian
energy system up to the 70′s (Bartoletto and Rubio, 2008), supporting
the development of the country postwar economy (Magazzino, 2014).
The necessity of energy for the reconstruction and the development of
new industrial production led to the exploitation of the country most
available energy sources and new coal mines were initiated throughout
Italy. According to the Italian Agency for Environmental Protection
(APAT, Agenzia per la Protezione dell’Ambiente e per i servizi Tecnici)
mining census, active mines in Italy reached their peak in the 50′s and
their development was associated to the construction of several coal
based thermal plants that included new reservoirs to serve the elec-
tricity generation (APAT, 2005).
The coal mining of the frst half of the 20th century caused sig-
nifcant environmental impacts due to the change in land use that af-
fected the existing ecosystems, determining a radical transformation on
the landscape functionality (Chadwick et al., 2013). In the second half
of 20th century coal use started to decrease, refecting the European
generalized decreasing trend (Li et al., 2019). At present electricity
generation from coal represents around the 13% of the total energy
produced in Italy (Littlecott and Schwartzkopf, 2015). The energy
national strategy supported the conversion of the existing coal-based
plants to more sustainable production systems, but the retirement of
mining sites became a major challenge also due to an incomplete policy
support (Littlecott, 2017). On one hand there is the necessity of mini-
mizing the social and economic consequences of restructuring and the
reducing the coal industry (Rabanal, 2003), on the other hand the ne-
cessity to identify the appropriate restoration measures to handle
landscape change and minimize the associated environmental impacts
(Zhengfu et al., 2010).
Water management plays a key role for determining strategies to
reduce these impacts, e.g. necessity of restoring natural drainage pat-
terns, implementing food control measures and restoring hydrological
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2020.125107
Received 29 November 2019; Received in revised form 16 March 2020; Accepted 21 May 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: tommaso.pacetti@unif.it (T. Pacetti).
Journal of Hydrology 589 (2020) 125107
Available online 04 June 2020
0022-1694/ © 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T