ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Treatment of Displaced Proximal Fifth Metatarsal Fractures Using
a New One-Step Fixation Technique
Thomas C. Koslowsky, MD, Thomas Gausepohl, MD, Konrad Mader, MD, Steffen Heck, MD,
and Dietmar Pennig, MD
Background: Fractures of the tuberosity of the fifth metatarsal are common
after foot twisting injuries, and operative treatment is recommended in cases
of displacement. The purpose of this study was to report the radiologic
outcome and clinical results of displaced fractures of the tuberosity of the
fifth metatarsal treated using fine-threaded K-wires (FFS).
Methods: In 3 years’ time, in a total of 35 cases, patients had an initial
fracture displacement of more than 2 mm for isolated extraarticular fractures
and an involvement of the cuboidal joint surface of more than 30%. After 15
months to 60 months (mean, 30.6), 32 of these patients participated in a
clinical follow-up examination and questionnaire according to a clinical
rating system for midfoot fractures. Radiologic outcome measurements were
the remaining postoperative intraarticular step off and the healing time.
Results: The mean midfoot scale score was 96.5 points. All the patients
returned to prior activities after operative treatment. Seven patients reported
minor pain during longer periods of walking. One patient with secondary
wound healing experienced frequent pain. Radiologically, in 32 of 35
patients, there was a remaining step off of less than 1 mm and in three
patients less than 3 mm. All fractures except one healed within the first 3
months to 6 months.
Conclusion: Operative treatment of displaced proximal fifth metatarsal
fractures using the FFS system leads to a good clinical and radiologic
outcome. The FFS system provides a new treatment option for this fracture
type.
Key Words: Fifth metatarsal fractures, FFS, One-step fixation system.
(J Trauma. 2010;68: 122–125)
A
twisting injury to the foot may result in a fifth metatarsal
fracture, a common fracture in outpatient orthopedic
settings.
1
Topographically, these fractures are subdivided into
fractures of the head, subcapital, mid-shaft, and basal frac-
tures.
2
Proximal or basal fractures present as injuries of the
metaphyseal-diaphysial junction (Jones fractures) or of the
tuberosity.
3
Conservative treatment is recommended for non-
displaced fractures of the tuberosity, and open reduction and
internal fixation (ORIF) is recommended for a displacement
of more than 2 mm with more than 30% of the cuboidal joint
involved.
2,4
The use of fine-threaded K-wires (FFS; Orthofix, Bus-
solengo, Italy) in small fragment fixation has been reported
previously and its clinical use was shown in several parts of
the body.
5–8
Here, we present the first clinical results, radio-
logic outcome, and operative technique in treatment of dis-
placed fractures of the fifth metatarsal using the FFS system.
METHODS
During a period of 4 years, a total of 35 patients (mean,
age 48.4; range, 24 – 88 years) with a displaced fracture of the
tuberosity of the fifth metatarsal have been treated using the
FFS system (Fig. 1). Metaphyseal-diaphysial junction frac-
tures (Jones fractures) have been excluded from this series,
because 3.5 mm malleolar screws were used for this type of
fracture. There were 13 male and 22 female patients. Twenty-
nine of the 35 patients, belonging to the older population, had
twisting injuries to the ankle. Five patients had direct trauma
to the foot and one patient was treated for a stress fracture to
the tuberosity. Diagnosis was performed by clinical exami-
nation followed by roentgenogram of the foot in three direc-
tions. Indication for operative treatment was present when the
fragment displacement was more than 2 mm and the fracture
involved more than 30% of the joint surface to the os
cuboideum. Three of the 35 fractures were extraarticular with
a displacement of the whole articular block with a dislocation
of more than 5 mm and a fracture line running toward the
amphyarthrosis of the fourth and the fifth metatarsal. In
addition to fragment displacement, we saw a rotation of the
fragments in these fractures during studies of the preoper-
ative roentgenograms. Eight of the 35 patients had more
than two intraarticular fragments. The operative procedure
was performed in a mean of 8 days (1– 45) after trauma as
a planned procedure. We saw one patient with an addi-
tional lateral malleolar ankle fracture treated with standard
plate fixation.
A tourniquet was used in all operations at our center. A
3-cm lateral skin incision was performed on the most prom-
inent part of the proximal fifth metatarsal. The proximal part
of the fifth metatarsal and the insertion of the peroneus brevis
tendon were revealed and the branches of the sural nerve
were protected. After the detection of the fracture gap, the
fracture hematoma was spilled out and the dislocated frag-
ment was reduced by a hook retractor (Fig. 2, A). In addition
to the direct view, fluoroscopy was used to assess the accu-
racy of reduction during FFS fixation. Depending on the
fragment size, a 2.2 mm or a 1.6 mm fine-threaded K-wire
Submitted for publication July 17, 2008.
Accepted for publication March 6, 2009.
Copyright © 2010 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
From the Department of Orthopedics, Traumatology, Hand and Reconstructive
Surgery, St. Vinzenz-Hospital, Cologne, Germany.
Address for reprints: Thomas Christian Koslowsky, MD, Joseph Teusch Strasse 7,
D-50935 Cologne, Germany; email: tkoslowsky@web.de.
DOI: 10.1097/TA.0b013e3181a8b355
122 The Journal of TRAUMA
®
Injury, Infection, and Critical Care • Volume 68, Number 1, January 2010