Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Accident Analysis and Prevention
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/aap
Self-reported handheld device use while driving
Karl Kim
a,b
, Jiwnath Ghimire
a,b
, Pradip Pant
a,b
, Eric Yamashita
a,b,
⁎
a
Department of Urban and Regional Planning, University of Hawaii, United States
b
National Disaster Preparedness Training Center, University of Hawaii, United States
ARTICLEINFO
Keywords:
Handheld device use
Distracted driving
Accident analysis
Prevention
ABSTRACT
In spite of research and awareness of the hazards associated with handheld mobile device use while driving,
many motorists continue to engage in this risky behavior. The mobile device use while driving has a detrimental
efect on the operation of the vehicle. It contributes signifcantly to distraction which is a leading cause of
accidents. Especially, the use of text messaging and the dialing of a 10-digit number while driving can be
attributable to crash risks. Phone use bans have a positive role in reducing mobile phone use for texting while
operating vehicles. There are limited studies on whether drivers admit to the use of handheld devices while
driving. The aim of this study was to identify the experiences, practices, and attitudes of handheld device use
while driving. A total of 337 respondents nationwide replied to the survey on the attitudes and self-reported
behaviors of handheld device use while driving. In the survey, the characteristics of handheld device users, use of
handheld devices, and the diferences in self-reported behaviors across states with and without device use re-
strictions were compared. The perceptions and experiences of device users are also examined. Based on the
background of device users and their attitudes, a multivariate logistic regression is used to identify the char-
acteristics of those who use handheld devices while driving. The model is relevant to this research because it
allows the consideration and comparison of many variables to identify the attitudes of people towards distracted
driving. The afrmative self-reporting of 59 percent of the respondents is a surprising result given that there are
state bans on texting and the use of handheld mobile phones while driving. Older drivers are least likely to
engage in these behaviors, compared to younger drivers and adult drivers. Based on the fndings, targeted
educational and enforcement campaigns to reduce device use during driving are suggested. Additional promising
areas for further inquiry and research are also proposed.
1. Introduction
There has been much research pointing to the impacts of mobile
phone use and distraction on driving performance (Oviedo-Trespalacios
et al., 2016) using a diverse array of methods including crash analysis
(Svenson and Patten, 2005; McCartt et al., 2006), with instrumented
vehicles (Caird et al., 2014a, b) naturalistic observations (Caird et al.,
2014a; Ferdinand and Menachemi, 2014), and driving simulators
(Törnros and Bolling, 2005; Ranney, 2008; Collet et al., 2010; Caird
et al., 2014a). Based on a review of the published literature, there is
evidence of the detrimental efects of mobile phone use while driving
(Lipovac et al., 2017) with text messaging associated with the highest
levels of distraction, followed by ten-digit dialing (Ranney et al., 2011).
Research has shown that crash risk can be attributable to drivers talking
on cell phones while driving (McEvoy et al., 2005; Márquez et al., 2015;
Sun and Jia, 2016). There are defciencies on reporting on the use of
mobile phones that result in road trafc accidents around the world
even though there are legislative bans on mobile phone use while
driving in those nations (Ige et al., 2016).
While handheld cell phone use has declined over the past decade
(2006–2015), visible manipulation of handheld devices has continued
to increase according to the National Occupant Protection Use Survey
(NOPUS), which shows device use is highest among young drivers, aged
16–24, and among female drivers over male drivers (Pickrell et al.,
2016). Research in 2012 found that 11% of drivers reported always
answering their phones while driving, and 17% report almost always
answering while driving with more than half (58%) continuing to drive
while completing their conversations (Tison et al., 2011; Schroeder
et al., 2013). Between 2005 and 2008, there was a 28% rise in the
fatalities from distracted driving and one of the major reason was the
rise in texting (Wilson and Stimpson, 2010). In a recent three month
analysis of 3 million drivers taking 570 million trips, amounting to 5.6
billion miles, Zendrive Research found that drivers use their phones 88
out of 100 trips (Zendrive Research, 2017). As to factors which lower
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2019.01.032
Received 12 January 2018; Received in revised form 14 December 2018; Accepted 27 January 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: karlk@hawaii.edu (K. Kim), jiwnath@hawaii.edu (J. Ghimire), pradip@hawaii.edu (P. Pant), ericyama@hawaii.edu (E. Yamashita).
Accident Analysis and Prevention 125 (2019) 106–115
0001-4575/ © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T