DOI: 10.1002/ejic.201600296 Full Paper
Cytotoxic Carbene Complexes
Selective Formation of cis-N-Heterocyclic Carbene-Pt
II
-Pnictogen
Complexes and in vitro Evaluation of Their Cytotoxic Activities
toward Cancer Cells
Mathilde Bouché,
[a]
Georges Dahm,
[a]
Aline Maisse-François,
[a]
Thierry Achard,*
[a]
and
Stéphane Bellemin-Laponnaz*
[a,b]
Abstract: A series of heterotopic platinum complexes combin-
ing N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) and pnictogen-based ligands
[Pn = P(nBu)
3
, PPh
3
, AsPh
3
and SbPh
3
] has been synthesized
and fully characterized. Use of an excess of Pn ligand led to the
formation of cationic bis-Pn platinum-NHC complexes in high
yield, with both Pn ligands being arranged trans to each other.
Several representative complexes could be characterized by X-
Introduction
Since the isolation of the first stable N-heterocyclic carbene by
Arduengo,
[1]
the chemistry of NHCs has become rich and is still
a very fertile field of investigation for both homogeneous catal-
ysis and organometallic chemistry.
[2,3]
Despite this rapid devel-
opment, application in other fields remains marginal, although
in the last few years interest in investigating NHCs in underex-
plored fields has grown.
[4]
For example, the unique properties
of NHC metal complexes make them attractive for the develop-
ment of metallodrugs.
[5]
In particular, the strong carbene–metal
bond enhances the stability of the entire system in the blood-
stream.
[6]
Interesting antimicrobial properties have also been
reported for various NHC metal complexes.
[6]
Of late, for exam-
ple NHC-copper,
[7]
gold,
[8]
palladium,
[9]
platinum,
[10]
and silver
complexes
[11]
were highlighted as auspicious anticancer
agents.
[12]
Among these investigations, the development of
new platinum-based complexes to overcome severe side effects
and cell-resistance phenomena encountered with cisplatin is of
great importance.
[13]
In addition, the poor selectivity of this
world bestselling drug and its efficiency toward a limited num-
ber of cancers remains an issue.
In the development of NHC-platinum anticancer drugs, Mari-
netti and co-workers nicely showed that neutral mono- and
[a] Institut de Physique et Chimie des Matériaux de Strasbourg (IPCMS), DMO,
Université de Strasbourg-CNRS UMR 7504,
23 rue du Loess, BP 43, 67034 Strasbourg, France
E-mail: bellemin@unistra.fr
achard@ipcms.unistra.fr
http://www.ipcms.unistra.fr/
[b] University of Strasbourg Institute for Advanced Study (USIAS),
5 allée du Général Rouvillois, 67083 Strasbourg, France
Supporting information and ORCID(s) from the author(s) for this article are
available on the WWW under http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ejic.201600296.
Eur. J. Inorg. Chem. 2016, 2828–2836 © 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 2828
ray crystallographic studies thus confirming the ligand arrange-
ment around the metal. This simple approach allows the gener-
ation of diversity in metallodrug candidates. Biological activities
on various human cancer cells have been studied and com-
pared with those of cisplatin. The results confirmed the high
cytotoxicity of these NHC-platinum complexes bearing pnicto-
gen ligands.
bimetallic trans-(NHC)PtX
2
(amine) complexes are active mol-
ecules against several types of cancer, including cisplatin-resist-
ant cancer cell-lines.
[10]
Cationic NHC-Pt
II
complexes also exhib-
ited high cytotoxicity against HeLa (cervical cancer) and HepG
2
(hepatocellular carcinoma) cell lines.
[14]
The easily available
[(NHC)Pt
II
X
2
] unit has been established as a useful molecular
building-block to generate libraries of anticancer analogues ei-
ther by postfunctionalization
[15]
or by ligand exchange.
[16]
Pnictogen ligands (Pn), and more precisely phosphine, are
ubiquitous in coordination chemistry of platinum(II) complexes.
Nevertheless, the number of pnictogen-containing Pt com-
plexes described decreases upon going down group 15 of the
periodic table.
[17]
Only a few examples of NHC-Pt complexes
combined with P,
[18–20]
As,
[18]
and Sb
[21]
ligands have been de-
scribed. Arsenic and antimony derivatives have been known for
decades for their biological activities and are still investigated
for medical applications.
[22]
Accordingly, a combination of the
(NHC)Pt molecular building-block and pnictogen ligands would
be an interesting system with which to investigate possible syn-
ergetic effects.
[22a,23]
Such an effect has recently been observed
by O'Halloran and co-workers while studying anticancer proper-
ties of a platinum/arsenic compound (arsenoplatin); in this case,
higher cytotoxicity than either cisplatin or As
2
O
3
was noted in
both colon cancer and glioblastoma.
[24]
The use of tertiary
arsine ligands in combination with platinum is also known to
induce interesting biological activities against tumor cells.
[25]
We report herein the synthesis of platinum(II) complexes
combining N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) and pnictogen-based
ligands [Pn = P(nBu)
3
, PPh
3
, AsPh
3
and SbPh
3
] (Figure 1). Syn-
theses were conducted under very mild reaction conditions and
provided a large library of NHC-Pt
II
-Pn complexes, all as single
stereoisomers with cis-configuration.
[26]
A series of cationic
platinum complexes was also synthesized, thus increasing the