Using a Community Health Development
Framework to Increase Community
Capacity
A Multiple Case Study
Whitney R. Garney, PhD, MPH; Monica Wendel, DrPH; Kenneth McLeroy, PhD; Angela Alaniz, BS;
George Cunningham, PhD; Billie Castle, MPH; Monique Ingram, MPH; James Burdine, DrPH
The Physical Activity and Community Engagement Project utilized a comparative case study to understand
how a theoretical framework called community health development (CHD) influences community capacity.
Three rural communities (cases) developed interventions using a CHD framework. Researchers collected
qualitative evidence measuring capacity and the CHD process for more than 3 years. Patterns identified seven
capacity constructs relevant to CHD, including community history, civic participation, leadership, skills,
resources, social and interorganizational networks, and critical reflection. Community health development
focuses on population health improvement and strengthening community capacity. As such, it helps
communities address local priorities and equips them to address future issues.
Key words: community health, obesity, physical activity/exercise, qualitative methods
T
HE CONCEPT of community is complex, with
a long history of how “community” has been
framed and operationalized over time. From a the-
oretical perspective, scholars have attempted to con-
struct a defnition of community that represents its
multidimensional aspects.
1
In 1975, Hunter
2
de-
fned comminutes as (1) functional spatial units that
meet basic needs for sustenance; (2) units of pat-
tered social interaction; and (3) symbolic units of
collective identity. Almost 20 years later, Eng and
Parker
3
expanded the defnition of community to
add a focus on producing political change. To oper-
ationalize the concept more practically, researchers
developed a typology that focuses on communities
as setting, target, resource, or agent.
1
As the concept of community has evolved, re-
searchers have developed various approaches for
Author Affiliations: Department of Health and Kinesiology, Texas
A&M University, College Station (Drs Garney and Cunningham);
University of Louisville, School of Public Health, Louisville, Kentucky
(Dr Wendel and Mss Castle and Ingram); and Center for Community
Health Development, Texas A&M Health Science Center School
of Public Health, College Station (Drs McLeroy and Burdine and
Ms Alaniz).
The Center for Community Health Development is a member of the
Prevention Research Centers Program. Funding was made pos-
sible (in part) by cooperative agreement number 1U48 DP001924
from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Correspondence: Whitney R. Garney, PhD, MPH, Department of
Health and Kinesiology, Texas A&M University, TAMU 4243 College
Station, TX 77843 (wrgarney@tamu.edu).
Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
DOI: 10.1097/FCH.0000000000000135
community-based work to ensure that communities
have a meaningful voice in projects.
4
Community
organizing surfaced in the 1800s as a way to co-
ordinate efforts for new immigrants in the United
States.
5
Since then, mobilizing efforts have ad-
vanced into more topic-oriented approaches, such
as community development, which capitalizes on
communities as an agent of change. Community
development is a broad term referring to activ-
ities aiming to mobilize and equip residents to
strengthen or improve conditions in their commu-
nity. Community development often targets a par-
ticular outcome, such as community health develop-
ment (CHD), which uses community development
processes to improve population health.
6
Simply stated, the process of CHD engages com-
munities to (1) identify local issues and resources,
(2) develop creative ways to address local issues
with available resources, and (3) implement sustain-
able health improvement strategies.
6
As Burdine
and colleagues
6,7
stated, CHD helps mobilize com-
munities to solve their own health-related problems.
It focuses on addressing community-prioritized is-
sues and in the process, builds local capacity by
helping communities obtain skills to address their
health issues in a contextually appropriate way.
CHD guides sustainable health improvement by
starting where people are.
8
Previous studies using
CHD principles have addressed access to mental
health services, community socioeconomic status,
and coordination of health and human services.
9,10
THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS
The CHD is an interdisciplinary, community-
driven framework used to mobilize local resources
Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
18 Family and Community Health January–March 2017 ■ Volume 40 ■ Number 1