Health and Social Care in the Community 8(4), 235–241
© 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd 235
Abstract
It is widely acknowledged that many women prefer to receive their
antenatal care in the community. This paper explores one explanation for
why this may be the case. The paper is based on a qualitative study of 19
primagravidae, aged between 16 and 30 years, who were interviewed
using the technique of repeated in-depth interviewing. The aim of the
research was to explore the relationship between women’s experiences
of pregnancy and the maintenance of self-identity during this time. The
research findings indicate that the relationship between the midwife and
her antenatal patient can foster both a sense of similarity to others and a
sense of personal uniqueness, which appear essential to the maintenance
of self-identity during pregnancy. Good communication seems to be an
essential tool for the community midwife, as it allows patients to normalise
their experiences and yet feel that their experiences of pregnancy are
unique. The findings indicate that continuity of care may be important in
fostering a sense of similarity to others and that continuity of carer may
be required to ensure uniqueness.
Keywords: antenatal care, communication, community midwifery, self-
identity, similarity, uniqueness
Accepted for publication 3 February 2000
Blackwell Science, Ltd
Pregnancy and the maintenance of self-identity: implications for antenatal care
in the community
Sarah Earle BA (Hons) PhD
Lecturer in Health Sociology & Policy, School of Health & Policy Studies, Faculty of Health & Community Care,
University of Central England, Perry Barr, Birmingham UK
Correspondence
Sarah Earle
Lecturer in Health Sociology & Policy
School of Health & Policy Studies
Faculty of Health & Community Care
University of Central England
Perry Barr
Birmingham B42 2SU
UK
E-mail: sarah.earle@tesco.net
and
sarah.earle@uce.ac.uk
Introduction
This paper explores the relationship between the
nature of antenatal care and the maintenance of a
woman’s self-identity during pregnancy. Self-identity
has been conceptualised in distinct ways although it is
generally agreed that self-identity is constructed vis
à vis others. In particular, this paper focuses on the
relationship between the community midwife and her
patient, and the way in which this relationship enables
women to maintain a coherent self-identity during this
time. The fact that the majority of women prefer their
antenatal care to be in the community has already
been established (Perkins & Unell 1997). However, this
paper attempts to develop one explanation for why
this may be the case. Drawing on a series of repeated,
in-depth interviews with 19 primagravidae, this paper
explores the way in which antenatal care in the com-
munity allows women to maintain both a sense of
uniqueness and similarity to other pregnant women.
Methods
This paper draws on a qualitative study of women’s
experiences of pregnancy and childbirth conducted in
May 1995, the aim of which was to explore the relation-
ship between their experiences and the maintenance of
self-identity. In order to recruit respondents to the study,
14 antenatal clinics in the Midlands were contacted
and asked for their co-operation. After receiving appro-
priate ethical approval from the Hospital Medical Ethics
Committee, 12 clinics agreed to participate. Women
were approached whilst they were waiting for their
antenatal appointment and were invited to participate