A publication of
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING TRANSACTIONS
VOL. 31, 2013
The Italian Association
of Chemical Engineering
Online at: www.aidic.it/cet
Guest Editors: Eddy De Rademaeker, Bruno Fabiano, Simberto Senni Buratti
Copyright © 2013, AIDIC Servizi S.r.l.,
I SBN 978-88-95608-22-8; I SSN 1974-9791
Modelling of LNG Pool Spreading on Land with Included
Vapour-Liquid Equilibrium and Different Boiling Regimes
Omar Basha
a
, Yi Liu
a
, Marcelo Castier
a
, Tomasz Olewski
a
, Luc Vechot*
a
,
Sam Mannan
b
a
Texas A&M University at Qatar, PO Box 23874, Doha, Qatar
b
Mary Kay O’Connor Process Safety Center, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA
luc.vechot@qatar.tamu.edu
This paper presents a source term model for estimating the rate of unconfined LNG pool spreading on
land. The model takes into account the composition changes of a boiling mixture, the variation of
thermodynamic properties due to preferential boiling in the liquid mixture and the effect of boiling regime
on conductive heat transfer. The heat, mass and momentum balance equations were solved for
continuous and instantaneous spills. A sensitivity analysis was conducted to determine the relative effect
of each of these phenomena on pool spreading. The model was compared to a commonly used gravity-
inertia integral pool-spreading model with one-dimensional conductive heat transfer.
1. Introduction
Although some pool spreading models have been developed as outlined by Webber et al. (2010), most of
them are integral models and based on work carried out in the early 1970’s on non-volatile liquid spills.
These early models tend to overlook the complexity associated with cryogenic pool spreading. Cryogens
(e.g. LNG: boiling point = -162 °C) exhibit vigorous boiling upon being released on land or water at ambient
temperature. In the case of an LNG release, some of the LNG will flash while rest will spread very quickly.
The conditions of heat transfer from the surroundings and the composition of the LNG mixture may affect
the spread rate and the vaporization rate. Most of the current modelling work on LNG spillage estimates
the LNG properties either using fixed thermo-physical properties of a mixture or using those of pure
methane as an analogue. This is questionable since the vaporization behaviour of a mixture is different
from that of a pure fluid due to preferential boil-off of the lighter hydrocarbons, which in turn results to time
varying properties of the spilled mixture.
The complex phenomena governing the spread and vaporization of a LNG pool have to be accounted for
and their relative importance must be understood to develop a comprehensive model that is both
adaptable and applicable to a variety of scenarios. In this paper, a pool-spreading model that takes into
account the composition changes of a boiling LNG mixture, the effect of different boiling modes on
conductive heat transfer as well as the varying mixture thermodynamics and vapour liquid equilibrium
effects is proposed. A sensitivity analysis is conducted to identify the relative importance of each of the
governing parameters on the pool spreading process. The model incorporates the multicomponent nature
of LNG and its effect on the behaviour of the spill with the aim of developing the most accurate and
comprehensive representation of the pool spreading process.
2. Pool spread modelling – base case
The pool spreading models developed and discussed in this paper were chosen and used to identify the
relative importance of the phenomena involved in the pool spreading process of a cryogenic liquid mixture
like LNG on land. This was achieved by defining a base case model and comparing it with pool spreading
models which differ from the base case by the addition of one of the following phenomena: heat transfer
boiling regimes and vapor liquid equilibrium (VLE).
43