Landslides
DOI 10.1007/s10346-019-01338-w
Received: 1 August 2019
Accepted: 18 December 2019
© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany
part of Springer Nature 2020
G. Pappalardo I S. Mineo I S. Imposa I S. Grassi I A. Leotta I F. La Rosa I D. Salerno
A quick combined approach for the characterization
of a cliff during a post-rockfall emergency
Abstract The research presented in this paper is aimed at testing
an innovative surveying protocol based the integration of quick
methodologies employed for the characterization of a carbonate
cliff affected by a rockfall and showing signs of further instability.
During a post-rockfall emergency, one of the most important
activities is evaluating if reactivation of the movements is possible,
and if it may represent a threat for a series of elements at risk. On 5
January 2019, intense rainfalls triggered the detachment of a sig-
nificant volume of fractured limestone and dolostone below the
main square of a historical village located in southern Italy in the
municipality of Messina, giving rise to one of the greatest land-
slides occurred at one of the most tourist areas of northeastern
Sicily. Fallen blocks damaged the two main infrastructures of the
area reaching also a bus terminal, which fortunately was vacant at
the time of the rockfall. With the aim of proposing a quick
surveying protocol during a post-rockfall emergency, terrestrial
laser scanner, infrared thermography, and horizontal to vertical
spectral ratio surveys were employed for the geostructural charac-
terization of the cliff and for the investigation of the subsoil below
the main square. In particular, the survey through terrestrial laser
scanner returned an accurate 3D model of the cliff, where some key
structures were highlighted; infrared thermography allowed recog-
nizing caves and fractures along the cliff, with specific reference to a
hollow area arising from past rockfalls. Such remote data, along with
direct rock mass surveys performed by expert climbers allowed
ascertaining that the instability of this cliff is driven by wedges
formed by the intersection of 2 and 3 discontinuity systems, which
are likely related to the main tectonic systems of the area. The
horizontal to vertical spectral ratio survey allowed the identification
of a peculiar vertical contrast of impedance, which may be related to
a mechanical discontinuity located below the main square of the
village, well matching with one of the systems responsible of the
instability. The integration of these surveys methodologies resulted a
useful quick protocol for the achievement of the key information on
the stability of a rock cliff in the initial stage of its securing.
Keywords Rock cliff
.
Rockfall
.
Infrared thermography
.
Laser
scanner
.
HVSR
Introduction
In a post-rockfall emergency, the quick survey of affected areas is
essential to ensure a rapid characterization of the problem, fore-
cast its potential evolution and suggest the most suitable urgent
remedial measures. To this purpose, the integration of quick sur-
vey methodologies is welcomed for the management of the emer-
gency, especially when no previous engineering-geological data are
available and the most exposed elements at risk have to be located.
When the setting of rock cliffs does not offer suitable spots for
direct rock mass surveys or the unstable rock volumes are located
at relevant heights, the remote and/or indirect analysis of the main
geostructural features is a feasible solution to achieve reliable data.
The recent technological development in the analysis of slope
instability has highlighted the potential of some innovative, non-
destructive, and stand-alone survey methodologies acting from
both a remote position (e.g., terrestrial laser scanner, infrared
thermography) and in situ (geophysical HVSR prospecting). More
specifically, terrestrial laser scanner (TLS) provides detailed point
cloud data to obtain a highly accurate 3D model of the slope, thus
overcoming the limitations of traditional surveying methodologies
applied to high cliffs or to hardly accessible rock faces, although a
direct rock mass survey, when feasible, is welcomed for a more
realistic interpretation of TLS results. The scientific literature
offers numerous cases of TLS application for the study and mon-
itoring of rock masses (e.g., Lim et al. 2005; Rosser et al. 2005;
Armesto et al. 2009; Fanti et al. 2012; Abellán et al. 2013; Gigli et al.
2014a; Mineo et al. 2018). Its most significant advantage is the
possibility of achieving the accuracy of the best topographic in-
struments, thus ensuring a precise analysis of the rock face, with
the possibility of focusing on the main instability features.
Infrared thermography (IRT) is a particular imaging technique
based on the infrared radiation emitted by all forms of matter with
temperature above the absolute zero (Hillel 1998). Its application
to the rock mechanics as a diagnostic tool for instability phenom-
ena has still a limited case history. It allows building images
highlighting the thermal variations occurring along a rock slopes,
which can be related to specific features of the rock. The most
recent experiences proved the usefulness of IRT for either the
study of weathered unstable slopes, or the rock mass fracturing
characterization, or the remote survey and mapping of large land-
slides (Baroň et al. 2012; Casagli et al. 2017; Pappalardo et al. 2018a;
Pappalardo and Mineo 2019). Some application cases in literature
are focused on the integration between IRT and geomechanical
surveys and/or TLS (e.g., Gigli et al. 2014b; Martino and Mazzanti
2014; Mineo et al. 2015a, b; Teza et al. 2015; Pappalardo et al. 2016a).
The horizontal to vertical spectral ratio (HVSR) is an indirect
geophysical surveying methodology employed for the calculation
of the spectral ratio between the mean horizontal on the vertical
components of the ground motion (Nakamura 1989). HVSR tech-
nique allows identifying the amplification frequency of the ground
motion due to resonance effects. This can be related to the pres-
ence of tectonic and/or stratigraphic discontinuities, landslides, or
peculiar local conditions. Several authors employed HVSR tech-
nique to get information on the seismostratigraphy features of the
subsoil (e.g., Lermo and Chavez-Garcia 1993; Lachet and Bard 1994;
Ibs-von Seht and Wohlenberg 1999). Pappalardo et al. (2016b)
coupled this survey method to geostructural analyses to reconstruct
the degree of fracturing of a rock cliff in a cultural heritage site
previously investigated from the geostructural point of view
(Imposa et al. 2010, 2015), while Imposa et al. (2017a) proved its
utility in the survey of a landslide body. A successful application was
achieved also by Pappalardo et al. (2018b), who detected a relict
landslide underneath an archeological site in Sicily.
Landslides
Original Paper