International Journal of Education
Vol. 14 No. 1, April-2021, pp. 30-38
©2021 Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia
doi: 10.17509/ije.v14i1.30553
30
Gender Stereotypes as Hidden Curriculum: A Case of Vietnamese English
Textbooks
Anh Phan
1
, Tho Xuan Pham
2
1
University of Auckland, New Zealand
2
University of Languages and International Studies, Vietnam
anh.phan@auckland.ac.nz
First draft received: 18 Dec 2020 Date Accepted: 31 March 2021 Final proof received: 28 Apr 2021
Abstract
Gender equality and women empowerment have become a buzzword for development during the past
decades with numerous national and international policies, including educational policies. However, gender
equality is normally conceptualized in quantitative terms of education such as low disparity in access to
education between boys and girls, while qualitative aspects of gender equality are still left uncontested,
among which is gender stereotypes in hidden curriculum. Gender stereotypes as a social construct, once
imbedded in education and educational materials, certainly intervene the gender socialization process of
students. The paper attempts to investigate this issue by employing a mixed qualitative and quantitative
content analysis of the illustrations in English textbooks for Upper-secondary students in Vietnam. The
analysis reveals stereotypes reflected in three main areas: occupations, sports and pastimes, and life
duties, all of which confirm social and cultural norms of Vietnamese society towards a woman.
Keywords: Gender stereotypes; gender socialization; hidden curriculum; Vietnamese English textbooks
To cite this paper (in APA style):
Phan, A., & Pham, T. X. (2021). Gender stereotypes as hidden curriculum: A case of Vietnamese English
textbooks. International Journal of Education, 14(1), 30-38. doi: 10.17509/ije.v14i1.30553
INTRODUCTION
Gender equality and women empowerment have
become a buzzword for development during the past
decades with NGOs, IGOs and governments using
this “fashionable concept” (Medel-Anovuevo &
Bochynek, 1995, p. 7) to include as one of their goals
in policy and strategy documents. One example is The
Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) established
following the Millennium Summit of the United
Nations, in which Goal 3 is to ‘Promote gender
equality and empower women’. The target is
eliminating gender disparity in primary and secondary
education preferably by 2015, specifically to have
more equal ratios of girls to boys in primary,
secondary and tertiary education. However, it can be
argued that gender equality does not simply lie in
equal access to education or equal opportunities to
the labour market. Worldwide studies show that
gender imbalances in education remain significant
obstructions to achieving gender equality (UNESCO
IBE, 2011). The study, henceforth, would like to
examine such mentioned imbalance, specifically
gender stereotypes in textbooks, or in other words,
how women and men are portrayed in education.
According to Bourdieu (2005, cited in Madureira,
2009), the macro-social level of analysis facilitates our
perception of “the reproduction of a hierarchical
structure of gender that expresses inequalities
between men and women in different domains”, for
instance autonomy, prestige or social status (p. 145).
Given the importance of textbooks in the Vietnamese
society, though being just a part of the national written
curriculum, textbooks can be seen as either vehicles
for such reproduction of social representations like
gender stereotypes or tools for gender equality
promotion (Levtov, 2014).
Although gender stereotypes are traditionally
examined in linguistical, verbal and textual materials,
we chose to focus on the illustrations, meaning the
pictures and drawings in the textbooks, and sought to
answer the question of what gender stereotypes are
embedded in the illustrations of English textbooks for
Vietnamese Upper-secondary students. To examine
this issue, a mixed qualitative and quantitative content
analysis method will be employed to analyze the
illustrations in the selected set of textbooks for Upper-
secondary (grade 10-12) students, coupled with the
findings from previous studies conducted on gender
stereotypes in textbooks for Primary students and
Lower-secondary students in Vietnam as analytical
points to shed light on this issue in Vietnamese
education.
Vietnamese cultural, political and educational
context
In order to understand gender stereotypes in the
Vietnamese education in general and in textbooks in
particular, it is essential to have an overall picture of
the cultural and political contexts in which the
Vietnamese education system is located.