Comparison of Trophic Magnification Slopes of Mercury in Temperate and Tropical Regions
Case Studies on the Oregon Coast, USA, Sanriku Coast, Japan, and Jakarta Bay, Indonesia
Adi Slamet Riyadi,
1,2
Takaaki Itai,*
1
Daisuke Hayase,
1
Tomohiko Isobe,
1,3
Sawako Horai,
1,4
Todd W. Miller,
1
Koji Omori,
1
Agus Sudaryanto,
2
Muhammad Ilyas,
2
Iwan Eka Setiawan,
2
and Shinsuke Tanabe
1
1
Center for Marine Environmental Studies (CMES), Ehime University, 2-5 Bunkyo-cho, Matsuyama, Ehime 790-8577
2
Agency for the Assessment and Application of Technology (BPPT), Jl. MH. Thamrin 8 Jakarta 10340, Indonesia
3
Center for Environmental Health Sciences, National Institute for Environmental Studies (NIES),
16-2 Onogawa, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8506
4
Department of Regional Environment, Tottori University, 4-101 Koyamacho-Minami, Tottori 680-8551
(E-mail: itai@sci.ehime-u.ac.jp)
The trophic magnification slope (TMS) of mercury has been
reported from >130 aquatic systems in the world. However, data
from the Asia-Pacific region is quite lacking despite the need for
estimation of Hg exposure via fish consumption in many of those
regions in the world. Here we provide TMS values from three
marine regions in the Pacificrim, Oregon coast, USA, Sanriku
coast, Japan, and Jakarta Bay, Indonesia. A decreasing trend of
TMS from temperate to tropical regions was found in this study.
Mercury (Hg) isawidely recognized global pollutant due to its
potential for long-range transport and high biomagnification
potential as methylmercury (MeHg).
1
Recent development of
numerical modeling coupling atmosphere-ocean Hg dynamics has
predicted high deposition of Hg in east to south-east Asia due to
its high emission from China and artisinal goldmining.
2,3
Once
deposited into ecosystems, inorganic Hg may be converted to
MeHg, which bioaccumulates in aquatic food webs.
4
Fishes inhigh
trophic position generally show high MeHg level thereby being the
biggest source of MeHg exposure to humans.
5
Therefore, increas-
ing deposition of Hg in the North Pacific cannot be overlooked by
concerned governments in Asia-Pacific as their people constantly
consume fish as an important source of animal protein.
6
In order to predict MeHg level by coupling atmosphere-ocean
dynamics models, the trophic magnification factor of total Hg
(THg) and MeHg through the food web should be known. Statistical
investigation has been recently developed by compiling literature
data from various freshwater and marine water systems.
7
The study
showed an increasing trend of trophic magnification slope (TMS),
the slope of regression curve between δ
15
N and Log[THg], with
latitude. However, the underlying mechanism of this trend is under
debate. Additionally, data from Asian tropical/temperate regions
are lacking (two fresh water sites in China and Masan Bay, Korean
marine site, Masan Bay) in Lavoie et al. despite 127 studies
(n = 101 in freshwater, n = 26 in marine water) being covered from
the entire world.
7-9
Apart from Lavoie et al., as far as we know, only
2 reports have been published from Asian marine sites,
10,11
while
freshwater systems in China have recently been investigated.
12
In this study, we provide TMS and trophic magnification
factor (TMF) from three regions in the Pacificrim, Oregon coast,
Sanriku coast, and Jakarta Bay. We chose these three regions based
on their oceanographic characteristics. The Oregon coast (43-48°N
along the west coast of North America) is in the cold temperate
region. The California Current is predominant in this region and
shows high productivity due to up-welling.
13
The Sanriku coast is
located on the temperate western Pacific (39°N, 142°E) where the
warm Kuroshio current and cold Oyashio current are flowing here
converting this region into a highly productive and thus a good
fishing ground.
14
Jakarta Bay (6°S, 107°E) is a representative
tropical eutrophic marine bay.
15
After calculating trophic magni-
fication parameters, factors controlling these are discussed by
comparing other studies focusing on oceanographic properties.
Nine species of animals(n = 67) were collected from North-
ern California to the Oregon coast from June to September 2007,
15 species (n = 111) were purchased from the Sanriku coast in
September 2007, and 26 species (n = 57) were collected from
Jakarta Bay during August 2010. In the Oregon and Sanriku
coasts, zooplankton was collected by plankton net. All animals
were dissected and freeze dried for 24 h. Muscletissue from fish
and large crustacean were used while mantletissue was used for
cephalopod samples. Wholetissues of small fish, small crustacean
and zoo plankton were homogenized. Detailsof species are listed
in Table S1.
For the THg analysis, ca 0.2g of powdered dry sample was
digested by a microwave system (Start D, Milestone) using HNO
3
(Wako pure) in Teflon vials. Concentration of mercury was
determined by cold vapor-atomic absorption spectrometry (CV-
AAS, Hiranuma HG-400 series).
Methyl mercury was selectively extracted with toluene
followed by back-extraction to a 4mM thiosulfate solution. The
aliquot was digested with the microwave system followed by the
determination by CV-AAS.
For the isotope ratio analysis, subsamples were dried for 24 h
at 60 °C and ground into powder with a mortar and pestle. The
solvent-extractable lipid fraction was removed from the subsample
and the lipid-free residues were centrifuged using microtubes
and dried at room temperature and later at 60 °C for 24 h. One
milligram powder subsamples were packed into 4-6 mm tin
capsules for stable isotope measurements. Stable isotopes were
measured using ANCA-SL mass spectrometer (PDZ Europa Ltd.).
Isotope ratios of carbon (δ
13
C) and nitrogen (δ
15
N) are expressed
as the deviation from standards in parts per thousand (‰)
according to the following equation:
X ¼ ½ðR
sample
=R
standard
Þ 1 1000 ð1Þ
where X is
15
N or
13
C and R is the corresponding ratio
15
N/
14
N or
13
C/
12
C. Standard for
15
N and
13
C are atmospheric N (air) and the
PDB standard, respectively.
TMSs and TMFs were calculated as follows. The definition of
TMS are the slope (b) of regression of eq 2.
Log
10
½Hg¼
15
N ðbÞþ a ð2Þ
CL-150579 Received: June 14, 2015 | Accepted: July 28, 2015 | Web Released: August 7, 2015
1470 | Chem. Lett. 2015, 44, 1470–1472 | doi:10.1246/cl.150579 © 2015 The Chemical Society of Japan