Poly L, DL-Lactic Acid, and Composite Poly L, DL-Lactic
Acid/β-Tricalcium Phosphate-Based Bioabsorbable
Interference Screw
Alex E. Santos,
1
Alex L. Braccialli,
1
Julio Vilela,
1
Cesar R. Foschini ,
2
*
Luiz E. A. Sanchez
2
1
Department of R&D of Sintegra Surgical Sciences Ltd., Medical Devices Company, Pompéia, SP, Brazil
2
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Sao Paulo State University – Unesp, Av. Eng. Luiz E. C. Coube 14-01,
Bauru, SP, CEP 17033-360, Brazil
There has been a growing interest in the use of bioab-
sorbable polymers in interference screws for knee liga-
ment reconstruction surgeries. This interest is driven by
virtue of the relevant properties exhibited by these poly-
mers. Among such essential properties include excel-
lent biocompatibility and bioabsorption, good
integration between graft/bone, in addition to the ease
they offer when it comes to surgical revision. This article
seeks to report the results obtained from the study
aimed at the development of a bioabsorbable interfer-
ence screw produced by the injection molding process
with two distinct polymeric materials: PLDL poly(L,DL-
Lactic acid) and a composite PLDL + 30 wt% TCP
(β-tricalcium phosphate). Finite element analysis (FEA)
was used for the development of the screw design. The
mechanical strength of the screws was evaluated,
where the maximum torque to break was found to sur-
pass the insertion torque by 136% in PLDL material and
by 190% in PLDL+TCP. The mean values of pullout force
obtained for PLDL and PLDL+TCP were 1635 N and
809 N, respectively. An in vitro degradation test per-
formed over a period of 180 days helped to assess the
mechanical behavior during degradation and facilitated
the comparison of the screws based on specific appli-
cation requirements. The composite material (PLDL
+TCP) exhibited a faster degradation process, with 88%
loss of mechanical resistance following 180 days of
degradation compared with 55% observed in the PLDL
material. The results show that the addition of bioactive
ceramic TCP contributed toward raising the initial
mechanical resistance and acceleration during the pro-
cess of degradation. POLYM. COMPOS., 2018. © 2018 Soci-
ety of Plastics Engineers
INTRODUCTION
Currently, the most widely used fixation devices in ante-
rior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructive surgery are the
interference screws. This is because their usage in fixing
provides an initial high strength and rapid bone integration,
thus allowing a quicker rehabilitation [1–3]. As a result,
the screws used in interference surgeries involving knee
ligament reconstruction have evolved from metal to bioab-
sorbable materials [4].
The reason for the use of bioabsorbable screws lies in
the fact that they allow the growth of host tissue upon the
screw degradation. Moreover, they do not present a major
risk of graft laceration and are more advantageous with
regard to MRI scans because they do not distort the image,
thereby facilitating revision surgery [5]. Bioabsorbable
screws are known to provide a secure initial fixation com-
parable to that of metal screws. By virtue of these relevant
factors, there has been a dramatic rise in the use of bioab-
sorbable materials for ligament reconstruction surgery in
recent times.
Bioabsorbable polymers have been used in several
applications, including biomechanical plates and screws for
fixation and stabilization of fractures, cages and spacers
used in spinal surgery [6].
The PLA has an additional methyl group in its monomer
(lactic acid), which makes it more hydrophobic. Its isomers
(L and DL – Lactic) possess different properties. The L-
isomer (polylactic acid or PLLA) becomes highly hydro-
phobic and crystalline over a prolonged degradation period
(many years). The DL-isomer is highly amorphous and less
stable—that is, it is characterized by a relatively more
accelerated degradation period [7].
The copolymer poly(L-lactide-co-DL-lactide) or PLDL
is less resistant to both hydrolysis and degradation. This
can be explained by the addition of DL-isomers in the base
polymerization of L-isomer, which renders the polymeric
chains longer and less compacted, resulting in relatively
lesser or no crystallinity, and consequently higher speed of
degradation. The crystallinity property of the polymers also
plays a role in defining the area in which they can be applied.
The PLDL material, which contains L- and DL-isomers, is a
Correspondence to: C. Foschini; e-mail: cfoschini@feb.unesp.br
DOI 10.1002/pc.25025
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com).
© 2018 Society of Plastics Engineers
POLYMER COMPOSITES—2018