This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON PLASMA SCIENCE 1
A New Concept for a Higher Burn-Up Fraction
Improvement in DEMO Reactor
Yuri Igitkhanov , Christian Day, and Stylianos Varoutis
Abstract—The possibility of improving the fuel burn-up frac-
tion by recirculating a part of the helium and fuel particles and
separating helium atoms from fuel atoms is investigated for the
DEMOnstration Power Plant conventional divertor configuration.
It is shown that the burn-up fraction can be considerably
improved by a continuous exhaust gas reinjection.
Index Terms—Burn-up fraction, DEMOnstration Power Plant
(DEMO), DEMO divertor, helium enrichment, helium recycling.
I. I NTRODUCTION
O
NE of the key challenges for a fusion power plant
is the need to significantly increase the fuel burn-
up fraction at least above 5% in order to make fusion
energy sufficiently attractive [1]. For 2-GW DEMOnstra-
tion Power Plant (DEMO) fusion power, the fueling rate
necessary to replenish the burnt fuel is rather small
(∼2.7 Pa m
3
/s) compared with the estimated fuel throughput
(∼200–350 Pa m
3
/s) needed mainly for the replenishment of
collateral fuel lost due to helium ash removal [2]. Therefore,
the fuel burn-up fraction is rather small (∼1%), indicating
the need to maintain the lowest possible fuel throughput for
reducing the required tritium inventory.
Different methods have been discussed to improve the
burn-up fraction and helium ash exhaust. The use of helium
retention in the first wall to keep the helium accumulation
below an admissible level is limited because of the wall
saturation, erosion, blistering, etc. For nonmetallic plasma-wall
interaction, helium recycling with the wall is large enough
so that under such high-recycling conditions, the exhaust of
several percent of the recycling helium particles is sufficient
to keep the helium concentration in the main plasma below
a permissible level. However, this situation is unrealistic in
DEMO, for which we expect an all-tungsten wall under high
wall temperature operation. The sufficient pellet fueling in the
hot high density active reactor zone in order to increase the
effective particle confinement time is still an open issue. As for
the helium ash exhaust, it is shown by Monte-Carlo simulation
that helium particles could be enriched in the divertor region
and the ash exhaust can be achieved by a relatively moderate
pumping speed [3]. The degree of enrichment is, however, not
Manuscript received June 30, 2017; accepted March 2, 2018. This work was
supported by EURATOM Research and Training Program 2014–2018 through
the EUROfusion Consortium under Grant 633053. The review of this
paper was arranged by Senior Editor E. Surrey. (Corresponding author:
Stylianos Varoutis.)
The authors are with the Institute of Technical Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of
Technology, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany (e-mail: stylianos.varoutis@kit.edu).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPS.2018.2814785
so high to allow for a considerable amount of fuel particles
to be pumped out simultaneously. Furthermore, experiments
in the detachment regime show that the plasma density in
the divertor region is fairly high. In this case, the enrichment
is further reduced and the amount of fuel pumped out may
become much larger. Another suggestion of helium separation
is to integrate a palladium alloy membrane in the pumping
port for selective pumping [4]. However, the erosion of the
membrane during the long-term operation could be a problem.
In this paper, we propose a new concept, which is based
on the organization of a recirculation of helium and fuel
particles between the divertor plenum and the scrape-off layer
(SOL) . This approach can be considered as a variant of the
direct recycling concept presented in [5]. This recirculation
will reduce the amount of fuel eventually to be pumped
out. The reduction can be achieved by employing the fact
that the helium atoms after neutralization on the divertor
plate readily penetrate into private flux region (PFR), thus,
further increasing the helium enrichment in the divertor. This
will mitigate the load on the pumping system and reduce
the circulating fuel amount (especially reducing the tritium
inventory).
A divertor configuration with the vertical plates and particle
bypassing loop connecting the plenum with the SOL area at the
baffle region is suggested for facilitating the helium removal
with moderate pumping flow and, consequently, the tritium
inventory.
II. FUEL BURN-UP FRACTION
The fuel burn-up fraction is defined as the ratio of
burn-up fuel rate 8
burn
to the particle throughput 8
in
,
f
b
≡ 8
burn
/8
in
, where the particle throughput equals the sum
of the burn rate and the pumping rate: 8
in
= 8
burn
+ 8
pump
.
The burn rate can be expressed as 8
burn
= nV
a
/τ
F
and
the pumping rate as 8
pump
= nV/τ ∗
p
, where τ
F
is the
burning time, τ
F
= 1/nhσ
DT
v i, n is the plasma density and
the fusion rate hσ
DT
v i= 3.68 × 10
-18
T
-2/3
exp(-19.94 ·
T
-1/3
) m
3
/s [6], which strongly depends on the temperature
profile, and consequently, τ ∗
p
= τ
p
/(1- R) is the effective par-
ticle confinement time. Here, τ
p
is the particle loss time related
to the particle transport and R is the recycling coefficient. The
values are averaged over the plasma volume V and the volume
of active zone V
a
, where a stable fuel burn occurs. Using
the temperature and density radial profiles from [7] and [8],
the active zone for DEMO can be defined from the inequal-
ity: n
p
(r )τ
E
≤ 12T (r )/ E
α
hσv i
F
, where E
α
= 3.5 MeV,
τ
E
∼ 4 s, which for the DEMO reactor is fulfilled in the
0093-3813 © 2018 EU