Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 47 (2023) 103817
2352-409X/© 2022 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
A pXRF analysis of historic brick chemical data throughout the lake
Michigan Morainic region, United States
Lauren D. Finnigan
*
, Mark Golitko
University of Notre Dame, 296 Corbett Family Hall, Notre Dame, IN 46556, USA
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Historic preservation
Masonry repair
Cream City
Midwest
Archaeology
ABSTRACT
Prior research has identifed and grouped localized brick samples utilizing portable X-ray fuorescence (pXRF).
This work asks whether historic brick samples across a multiple-state regional area can be reliably grouped based
upon pXRF data. To answer this, pXRF readings (n = 718) were taken from sites or extant buildings (n = 36) in
Milwaukee, Wisconsin; Chicago, Illinois; Hobart, Indiana; South Bend, Indiana; The University of Notre Dame,
Indiana; and Zeeland, Michigan. Results indicate distinct chemical groupings that correspond with and represent
different brick production sites. In some cases, it is possible to identify the use of brick of more than one chemical
type within the same structure. This work is important because of the historic signifcance of bricks as an artifact
class. A rich history of brick production has become a crucial factor in the community identity for many of these
sites and the results of this project indicate that matching brick samples found in archaeological sites to their
production site with pXRF is promising. The results from this work also indicate that historic bricks that are to be
reused for contemporary repairs and construction projects can be accurately sourced based upon chemical data
supplied by pXRF analysis.
1. Introduction
This paper is the result of an extensive analysis into the material
properties of historic brick produced primarily around the lower lobe of
Lake Michigan. Bricks were produced in massive quantity through this
area in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, providing material for
explosive industrial and urban growth, and for co-constructing the built
environments of millions of people. A thorough understanding of the
chemical composition of these bricks allows researchers to map the
presence of various distinct brick types and to reconnect their regional
material history.
Historic bricks have achieved an importance that transcends their
indexical value to the communities that produced them. In the past 150
years some culturally signifcant brick buildings have suffered damage
from the multiple freeze–thaw cycles endemic to the lower Great Lakes.
The Rust Belt is considered a “severe weathering” area with one of the
higher weathering indices in the country (Gross and Plummer 1973, 12),
and because of the variance in material response to external cold
contraction or heat expansion, it is necessary to utilize similar bricks
when performing these repairs (L´ opez-Arce et. al. 2003, 59; Plumridge
and Meulenkamp 1993, 200; Schuller et. al. 2012, n.p.). If a brick or
masonry unit expands and contracts at different rates than the bricks
around it, this can lead to gapping, cracks, and eventual masonry failure.
This makes the accurate identifcation of brick samples increasingly
important to properly preserve these buildings or sites.
This project utilized pXRF to obtain chemical data on over 700 (n =
718) bricks from 36 buildings in six cities across four states (Wisconsin,
Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, see Fig. 1), including ex-situ, in-situ, com-
mon, and face bricks. Bricks present unique challenges in chemical
sourcing, including variable clay sources, unavailable historic docu-
mentation, and the capacity for mobile chemicals to leach into their
porous structure, especially in heavily industrialized environments.
Structures in the Rust Belt are especially susceptible to these industrial
impacts, and, with the acute need for replacement bricks for repairs, the
requirement for an accurate data set and reliable chemical analysis
method becomes increasingly important. The results from this work
provide the largest and geographically broad assessment to date of
historic brick using pXRF, determining that large-quantity, time-sensi-
tive analyses across regional areas is possible.
It is intended to demonstrate the value of brick as an artifact class as
well as the capability of portable X-ray fuorescence (pXRF) data ob-
tained from sites across a broad, multi-state, geographic area (~150
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: pfnnig1@nd.edu (L.D. Finnigan), mark.l.golitko.1@nd.edu (M. Golitko).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jasrep
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jasrep.2022.103817
Received 1 November 2021; Received in revised form 25 November 2022; Accepted 28 December 2022