55
CJCS 6 (1) pp. 55–73 Intellect Limited 2014
Catalan Journal of Communication & Cultural Studies
Volume 6 Number 1
© 2014 Intellect Ltd Article. English language. doi: 10.1386/cjcs.6.1.55_1
Keywords
argument
discourse
identity
journalism
political conflict
press
Cristina Perales
Universitat de Vic
ludivine thouverez
Université de Poitiers
Building spani sh and Catalan
identity in the debate on
banning bullfighting
1
aBstraCt
Catalonia’s ban on bullfighting, which was passed by the Parliament in July 2010,
caused a political and media commotion. This study analyses the arguments provided
by the Spanish press with the aim of verifying how the media is involved in the
conflict, accentuating the distance between advocates and abolitionists of the bull-
fighting tradition. The research compared editorials and opinion articles in Catalan
and Spanish leading newspapers, taking a discursive approach. The authors defend
that the comment columns did not add new perspectives to stories compared with
the opinions offered by the editorials of the newspapers and that these displayed the
bullfighting debate as a pretext for reaffirming their position with regard to identity.
After conducting a discursive analysis, the authors state that the media is under-
stood to be a political player whose actions influence the evolution of the conflict.
This can be done by means of the (de)legitimization of both, the discursively implied
participants and their actions. The discursive approach will be followed in order to
uncover how ideological beliefs are spread and how the selected newspapers help to
construct identity.
1. This research has
the support of the
‘Ministry of Science and
Innovation’ of Spain,
through the project ‘La
construcción mediática
de los conflictos
políticos y territoriales
en España. Estudio
de los discursos y
narrativas’ CSO-2010-
20047.